For now, I decided to keep it closed because I am concerned that it will only further fragment discussion. Like, I would rather have a "What to Do With Attacks, Generally" thread in the general forum, with occasional references to Donald X's post, than some discussion in the general forum and some more in the Donald X forum. After all, they span quite a few topics, and they aren't intended as discussion points so much as a reference guide as to "what the game designer intended".
If my plan doesn't actually work out very well, then I'll open it up.