Ok, so how would you go about figuring out the alignment of the good players, then.
Hoping that something out of the ordinary happens
But the default stuff is just not indicative and we should all be aware of that.
That's all fine and good, but you realize that you just gave yourself an excuse to not have any reads on the good players, right? That's concerning.
why is Robz your biggest townread, Lalight?
There is a reason.. it's not something i got to know at night, it's something i read from him. Not too strong of a proof, but quite.
Can you give me a more specific answer, or is it only gut?
I have to say, J Reggie seems waaaay too scummy to be scum. Am I the only one bothered by that?
well, J Reggie was obv!scum in M86 where we were partners, but was never lynched and we won. Actually this is one of the reasons why i'm voting for him.
Fair enough. But look at it from my perspective. You come back to the game, and you see that no one, as far as I can tell (aside from maybe a quick side comment by WW) is opposing a J Reggie lynch. What am I supposed to conclude from that?
In M86, was he obv!scum to you only, to everyone? Did people actually want to lynch him saying he was obv!scum? This is actually an important question. I will try to read M86 if I have the time (but then again, Christmas break and family).
Well, impressions change, sometimes very rapidly. Although it doesn't actually look like anyone changed their mind all that much there. So not sure why this is worth pointing out.
You did! You both were
all but certain that the other was town. Then Calamitas, Eevee and me expressed concern over how much you were buddying each other, and bam! You start suspecting each other.
Robz making comments about scum playing badly is very scummy. It shows a level of certainty that is just incongruent with the fact that it's D2 and we have not lynched a single scum.
When did I do this and why is it scummy?
You've done it a few times, but I have to run out to do some errands now, I will fish them out for you when I come back. It's scummy because, at this stage of the game, town should not be certain of anything. So you being so certain that scum has been playing badly is just... I don't see how you could know that, as town. As scum, it's easy to pretend that you know, though, and makes people more willing to follow you.
Oh, and I am voting Robz 50% because gut, 50% to see reactions. mcmc was the first to question the vote, and Robz waited until somebody else did to comment on it. So, there's that.
Valid to see reactions. I didn't comment on it because you didn't supply a reason, and then I commented that you hadn't supplied a reason.
That would be fair, only you waited until literally two posts after somebody else brought it up (mcmc) to feel like you could comment on it. I am not surprised that mcmc brought it up first, because well he's been buddying you so much.
On the other hand, everybody knows that worrying about people voting for you is scummy, so you waiting until somebody brought it up to feel like you could talk about it shows that you are concerned about what people could think of you, more than you are concerned about what could possibly be going through my mind, which would lead to interactions, etc.
In fact, you've been shadowing mcmc ever since he got back into the game, with barely any deviation from his opinion.
Not sure what to make of pacovf. I disagree with a lot of the opinions he's giving here.
Disagreements are good! It leads to meaningful interactions, potential tells, reads, and can they be interpreted as people flip.