Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EFHW]

Not only that, but if thinking about survival were towny, we would expect all town not nominated to vote yes (since it guarantees they’re not the day’s lynch).

That's a really big stretch. But feel free to ignore my townread, Awaclus didn't need it anyway so I don't know why we're spending so much time analyzing that (and only that). Where's all the joth/Glooble discussion? Or any other for that matter?

The "really big stretch" is joth extrapolating the implications of your statement that pubby is town because he was worried about surviving. You are shutting down discussion at the same time that you demand more discussion from everyone else.

[EFHW]

So you don't have a case, gotcha. Also, lazy answer, that's what anyone would instantly think of.

This is Robz's new meta. Be ostentiously lazy and make provocative anti-town suggestions. This has gotten him mislynched a couple times, but will probably end up being a good cover when he is scum.

[jotheonah]

Let's all do reads lists! That will be fun.

[jotheonah]

DatSwan -- neutral to town
Awaclus -- townier than normal, which actually could denote scum
jotheonah -- obv town. plz.
Glooble -- scumread
Joseph2302 -- scummish for pro-duel stance
2.71828..... -- most likely town
0Ix --
Debatepro -- neutral
MiX -- leaning town
EFHW -- excruciatingly townie
A Drowned Kernel -- leaning town
Robz888 -- trying to read day 1 Robz is a fool's errand, but also see: Joseph
pubby -- scummy in a vague way
mcmcsalot -- also highly townie

So I guess I want to re-read pubby, Awaclus, Robz & Joseph, and Debatepro.

[MiX]

Let's all do reads lists! That will be fun.

Hmm, I was going to reread, but I suppose a before/after reread list can't hurt...

DatSwan -- town
Awaclus -- towny, meh, Awaclus-towny
jotheonah -- town but his conviction is really poor. Could be scum with Glooble.
Glooble -- Scummy, scum with joth??? Weird.
Joseph2302 -- Scummy, not third-party, which is useless here.
2.71828..... -- voting yes' weird, somewhat towny
0Ix -- technically townier than null
Debatepro -- mislynch
MiX -- uuuh
EFHW -- towny
A Drowned Kernel -- towny enough to not be lynched (so probably scum, but not today)
Robz888 -- anti-town town
pubby -- town
mcmcsalot -- not dying today that's for sure


Hmm that's a lot of townreads. Let's see what happens after rereads...

[Awaclus]

Let's all do reads lists! That will be fun.

But I refuse.

[Glooble]

DatSwan - leaning town but still a tiny bit suspicious
Awaclus - he is acting less belligerent than usual, but I refuse to lynch him for that
jotheonah - not that scummy but scummier than anyone else to me right now
Glooble - town
Joseph2302 - null
2.71828..... - I could be convinced to vote here. I should reread.
0Ix - who?
Debatepro - can't remember anything he's done this game
MiX - townish
EFHW - town
A Drowned Kernel - probably town, despite our disagreements about how scum would act
Robz888 - null, this new meta sucks
pubby - was leaning scum, now leaning null
mcmcsalot - town

[A Drowned Kernel]

The scumteam: glooble, joth, mix
Everyone else is town

[MiX]

The scumteam: glooble, joth, mix
Everyone else is town

Dream team!

[A Drowned Kernel]

DatSwan - leaning town but still a tiny bit suspicious
Awaclus - he is acting less belligerent than usual, but I refuse to lynch him for that
jotheonah - not that scummy but scummier than anyone else to me right now
Glooble - town
Joseph2302 - null
2.71828..... - I could be convinced to vote here. I should reread.
0Ix - who?
Debatepro - can't remember anything he's done this game
MiX - townish
EFHW - town
A Drowned Kernel - probably town, despite our disagreements about how scum would act
Robz888 - null, this new meta sucks
pubby - was leaning scum, now leaning null
mcmcsalot - town

In all earnestness, I feel like there's way too much town and null on this list for it to be real

vote: glooble

[jotheonah]

Let's all do reads lists! That will be fun.

But I refuse.

color me surprised

[Glooble]

DatSwan - leaning town but still a tiny bit suspicious
Awaclus - he is acting less belligerent than usual, but I refuse to lynch him for that
jotheonah - not that scummy but scummier than anyone else to me right now
Glooble - town
Joseph2302 - null
2.71828..... - I could be convinced to vote here. I should reread.
0Ix - who?
Debatepro - can't remember anything he's done this game
MiX - townish
EFHW - town
A Drowned Kernel - probably town, despite our disagreements about how scum would act
Robz888 - null, this new meta sucks
pubby - was leaning scum, now leaning null
mcmcsalot - town

In all earnestness, I feel like there's way too much town and null on this list for it to be real

vote: glooble

If I had a strong scumread, or even a weak one, I'd be making a case on them.


And you'd better believe if I was scum I would have put a lot more scumreads on that list.

[Glooble]

As scum I would absolutely just make shit up, but I don't do that as town. So if I have no strong scumreads, you get a readlist with no strong scumreads.

[Glooble]

But seriously, why would I post a list like that as scum? "Oh, I'm about to get lynched, better deflect suspicion by saying... I think everybody is townie?"

Who does that?

[Awaclus]

But seriously, why would I post a list like that as scum? "Oh, I'm about to get lynched, better deflect suspicion by saying... I think everybody is townie?"

Who does that?

Well, now you are trying to deflect suspicion using the fact that you think everybody is townie as an argument. So apparently you do that.

[MiX]

But seriously, why would I post a list like that as scum? "Oh, I'm about to get lynched, better deflect suspicion by saying... I think everybody is townie?"

Who does that?

Someone who does not want to deflect to anyone in particular and knows that readlists without scum are too scummy to come from scum. Now, why wouldn't scum!Glooble want to deflect? Because either joth's scum (lol) or they think they can't lynch joth nor pubby and they don't know who else could be a real scumread from town!Glooble.

[A Drowned Kernel]

But seriously, why would I post a list like that as scum? "Oh, I'm about to get lynched, better deflect suspicion by saying... I think everybody is townie?"

Who does that?

"About to get lynched" is a pretty bizarre way to describe having two votes on you

[Glooble]

But seriously, why would I post a list like that as scum? "Oh, I'm about to get lynched, better deflect suspicion by saying... I think everybody is townie?"

Who does that?

"About to get lynched" is a pretty bizarre way to describe having two votes on you

It's not all about the number of votes.

[jotheonah]

The scumteam: glooble, joth, mix
Everyone else is town

Dream team!

for real

[jotheonah]

As scum I would absolutely just make shit up, but I don't do that as town. So if I have no strong scumreads, you get a readlist with no strong scumreads.

There is a third option you know, besides "make stuff up" and "make a list with no strong scumreads". I wonder if you can guess what it is...

[Glooble]

As scum I would absolutely just make shit up, but I don't do that as town. So if I have no strong scumreads, you get a readlist with no strong scumreads.

There is a third option you know, besides "make stuff up" and "make a list with no strong scumreads". I wonder if you can guess what it is...

Pull an Awaclus and refuse to make a list?

[jotheonah]

As scum I would absolutely just make shit up, but I don't do that as town. So if I have no strong scumreads, you get a readlist with no strong scumreads.

There is a third option you know, besides "make stuff up" and "make a list with no strong scumreads". I wonder if you can guess what it is...

Pull an Awaclus and refuse to make a list?

ooh I guess there were four. I was going for "reread the thread and develop some sincere scumreads"

[jotheonah]

I just iso'd pubby. ... what's the case there? He seems decently townie if a bit lurkish.

But you know who we should talk about? Awaclus! Anybody else feel like he's really off-meta? He's posting more, the posts are longer, and they're even helpful occasionally. I don't like it.

[Awaclus]

Anybody else feel like he's really off-meta? He's posting more, the posts are longer, and they're even helpful occasionally. I don't like it.

I don't think that's true?

[Awaclus]

I mean obviously my posts are helpful, otherwise I wouldn't post. I don't think I'm posting more or that the posts are longer.