Okay, so some reads:
First Kooshie. Her early defensiveness and eagerness to please read a bit scummy to me, but her slightly awkward defense read a little more like Newbie Town than Newbie scum. I think overall that leaves her on a very slight scum read.
Next sudgy. I think sudgy has become my biggest scumread, for a few reasons:
He's said a lot and given a lot of reads without actually giving many reasons or cases. That is, he seems to be saying a lot without saying much, and the reasons he has given haven't been that substantial. For example, raerae asking questions, raerae unvoting. Granted, a lot of that happened in semi-RVS, but the reasons were carried out of RVS. Then in his #435, he gives a view on everyone, and is giving "pretty big" reads, but very few reasons, or just other people's reasons. He's currently voting Kooshie without giving any of his own reasons, just talking about liopoil's "evidence", which is consistent with classic scum sheeping.
On that note, I still think this was scummy:
I'm fairly certain that either liopoil or kooshie are scum. They both seem pretty scummy to me, but with liopoil having a fairly-convincing argument against kooshie I'm pretty sure they couldn't both be it.
I just think this certainty is more likely to benefit scum sudgy than it is Town sudgy, and it also comes after sudgy called EFHW out for being certain of something:
Something I noticed, is that EFHW seemed awfully certain that raerae is mafia... Why is that?
Also note that EFHW's "certainty" of raerae's scumminess was based on the same reason that sudgy said raerae was scummy.
So it seems like if sudgy is scum, then he is following liopoil into the Kooshie lynch with the aim of blaming lio for it tomorrow and pushing for the lio lynch. I think this is enough for me to
Vote: sudgy and see what people think.