Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jimmmmm]

Assuming we do lynch mcmc, before we do so we really need thoughts from lio as to who he thinks is scummier out of yuma and Robz (and me I guess).

Also need to talk about yuma LRing tonight in the case that he is telling the truth. If mcmc isn't a Roleblocker/Jailkeeper, we'll probably be in the same situation tomorrow though.

[mcmcsalot]

The issue with lynching me is if you believe I am town I am a bomb, If you believe the fringe case where I made a terrible use of my jailkeep I am scum. Either way you know both of my potential roles. If yuma is town he is LR and it didn't go off and now he does nothing. If yuma is scum making a gambit on the LR claim, we have no clue what potential role he has.

If you want to lynch us both why am I the safer lynch for today. If we are both town I am more helpful, not by much, If we are both scum he is potentially more dangerous. With ash being the last cop and most likely going to be killed jailkeep will then be a useless power, so again even if I am scum jailkeeper, which I am not, why would you lynch me over scum yuma.

[Robz888]

Uh, if yuma truly was roleblocked, he has no LR shot left, right? No way he was an unlimited LR.

[ashersky]

Yuma was 1-shot, he said.

No one is shooting mcmc anyway, so his utility argument holds no water.

I'm fine with either dying at ths point.

If I die tonight, lynch the other one or jimmmmm tomorrow.

[ashersky]

Actually, here is an idea.

If we really think a town lynch today is okay, you could lynch me.  I'm not IC like Lio and you remove the obvious NK from the equation.

[Robz888]

Okay, I think we're just waiting for liopoil, now.

Liopoil: If the scum is jim/yuma, this is going to be entirely your fault, so, you know, no pressure.

[Robz888]

Actually, here is an idea.

If we really think a town lynch today is okay, you could lynch me.  I'm not IC like Lio and you remove the obvious NK from the equation.

What? Why would we do this? A town lynch is only okay if there's only 1 scum left. Which is definitely possible, there was only 1 death last night... but I don't think anybody really thinks you are scum..

[ashersky]

Okay, I think we're just waiting for liopoil, now.

Liopoil: If the scum is jim/yuma, this is going to be entirely your fault, so, you know, no pressure.

True.

[Robz888]

If mcmc and yuma are both scum, killing you ashersky could actually put us in, or close, to a no-win scenario. (The same is true if we kill mcmc and jim/yuma are scum.)

[ashersky]

Actually, here is an idea.

If we really think a town lynch today is okay, you could lynch me.  I'm not IC like Lio and you remove the obvious NK from the equation.

What? Why would we do this? A town lynch is only okay if there's only 1 scum left. Which is definitely possible, there was only 1 death last night... but I don't think anybody really thinks you are scum..

I'm a few beers in, so my planning may not be the best.

Lynch Yuma, then mcmc, then Jimmmmm.  That's my order of preference.

Just thought, well, if a town lynch is our safest play, I was willing to make the sacrifice.

[Robz888]

I agree with that order. I'm just not SO worried about doing mcmc first. But we have to do it whatever way liopoil wants, I guess.

[ashersky]

If mcmc and yuma are both scum, killing you ashersky could actually put us in, or close, to a no-win scenario. (The same is true if we kill mcmc and jim/yuma are scum.)

This makes sense.

I think an if, then list would be good.

If scum is Yuma/mcmc, then...
If scum is mcmc/Jimmmmm, then...
If scum is Yuma/Jimmmmm, then...

I don't know the thens. 

If Robz is scum, then we lose.  That one I know.

[liopoil]

I think mcmc is more likely to be scum then Yuma.

[mcmcsalot]

Liopoil please reread Yuma I believe from your posts you are basing this off of rememberence from the game. I also think you are letting my scum read on you affect your read on me, when in fact the fact Thani thought you were scum, even came into today thinking you didn't take your night kill to make it look like glooble and munch was the last of that team. I knew ash would've copped you, so why would I continue to push thinking you were scum if I knew you were town and knew you would soon be made ic.

[Robz888]

Lio, what about Jim or me? I think Jim wants that answered before we go to night.

[Robz888]

Well, lio just said he's V/LA until Wesnesday. Can't imagine it's worth it to wait.

[Robz888]

I think mcmc is more likely to be scum then Yuma.

Let's find out.

Vote: mcmcsalot

[Robz888]

Come on come on come on, flip time.

[Robz888]

Nothing to say, bro? I take this to mean you were indeed scum.

[jotheonah]

Vote Count 5.2

"I know it's, uh, not my place to say, but, it seems weird that General Martok's ship has been here the entire time this has been happening," Rom says to Garak as he's getting a suit fitted. "Do - do you think he might be the spy?"

"Hmmm," says Garak. "But he's such good friends with our erstwhile Captain, I'm afraid we'll never convince Starfleet to consider the possibility. I wouldn't worry about it." He smiles his wry smile.

The next day, everyone is shocked when General Martok's ship, the Rotarran, explodes with him and his crew on board.

But then Worf receives a strange communique from the Klingon homeworld. It's Martok!

"Woooorf, you old dog, how are you?"

"But General. You were killed. Just this morning."

"What? I haven't been to Deep Space Nine in months!"

A subspace quantum scan of the debris confirms it: The Martok who's been on the station this whole time was from the Mirror Universe!

mcmcsalot has been lynched. He was General Martok, the Mirror Universe-aligned Bomb.

yuma (2): ashersky, mcmcsalot
mcmcsalot (4): Jimmmmm, liopoil, yuma, Robz

Not Voting: no one!

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.
We can have another 24 hour night, or we can skip the weekend and start up again on Monday. Living players, please PM me your preference.

THREAD LOCKED

[jotheonah]

Game will start Monday morning. Night actions due by midnight Sunday.

[jotheonah]

The promenade has been returned to its pre-occupation days. With Worf's untimely death (devolved into a lizard after eating some bad gagh), no Starfleet personnel remain, and the highest ranking Bajoran officer is actually Rom, who has neither the propensity nor the desire to keep order. There is widespread looting and destruction.

ashersky has been killed. He was Worf, the Station-aligned Maquis Cop

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.
Deadline is march 4th at 8 am

[Jimmmmm]

And we're back. lio, as our resident IC, who do you see as the least and most Towny at this point in time?

[Jimmmmm]

Updated Living:

2. Robz - 1-Shot Tracker/Kasida Yates
3. yuma - 1-shot Lightning Rod/Elim Garak
9. liopoil - Neighbor/Rom (Confirmed TOWN)
11. Jimmmmm - Beloved Princess/Vadek Antos (Confirmed NOT MU)

Possible MU: Robz, yuma

Possible Maquis: Robz, yuma, Jimmmmm

It seems by far most likely that there is exactly one scum left, the third Maquis, so confirmed non-MU means nothing for me. Obviously from my point of view it's either Robz or yuma. If we're to follow ash's major Town read on Robz, that means it must be yuma, which is consistent with yuma "lying" about the LR. The other possibility, of course, is that Robz is a Jailkeeper or something, and prevented yuma's LR.

[Jimmmmm]

If we lynch yuma, I want it to be on more than just the LR thing. lio and the other Townie, I think we should all put in a re-read of all our possible lynch candidates so we can make the best possible choice.