Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[MiX]

I should've written down answers to your big posts while I was dead, actually. I just didn't think I could solve this game better than everyone else. I'm honestly kinda lost.

Is the play to reread joth and see who's partners with him?

I do see a flaw in your logic: given LaLight's role, it's very much possible that scum!Awaclus had something that makes him townie. Isn't that the whole point of LL's thing? Thus he can be scum.

What do you mean, something that makes him townie? Like he could alignment switch?

Like he could have an ability that when LL checks it looks townie. Because LL exists, everything needs to be worded somewhat townie.

[faust]

I do see a flaw in your logic: given LaLight's role, it's very much possible that scum!Awaclus had something that makes him townie. Isn't that the whole point of LL's thing? Thus he can be scum.

What do you mean, something that makes him townie? Like he could alignment switch?

Like he could have an ability that when LL checks it looks townie. Because LL exists, everything needs to be worded somewhat townie.

It seems nonsensical to have a scum host with a role that says "you don't count for town's win condition". I don't think abilities would include such pointless fluff just for the sake of LaLight's role.

[MiX]

I do see a flaw in your logic: given LaLight's role, it's very much possible that scum!Awaclus had something that makes him townie. Isn't that the whole point of LL's thing? Thus he can be scum.

What do you mean, something that makes him townie? Like he could alignment switch?

Like he could have an ability that when LL checks it looks townie. Because LL exists, everything needs to be worded somewhat townie.

It seems nonsensical to have a scum host with a role that says "you don't count for town's win condition". I don't think abilities would include such pointless fluff just for the sake of LaLight's role.

It's definitely possible if the setup wasn't hand picked. Given how this game's going, this doesn't seem like a typical role distribution either.

[faust]

There is also the fact that ADK claimed to me to have received an answer that conflicts with what mail-mi said. If we think mail-mi is town, it should follow that ADK is scum.

Also noone has so far claimed to have talked to ADK tonight. If they were town, they would have tried to talk to a townie.

[faust]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

[MiX]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

If ADK is scum, why did scum target scum? If they just shot joth...why even do that?

We're like missing all the pieces. Why does LaLight not have a single incriminating result?

[faust]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

If ADK is scum, why did scum target scum? If they just shot joth...why even do that?

For towncred. Isn't it obvious? Kill scum, have them resurrected, be townread for eternity.

[MiX]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

If ADK is scum, why did scum target scum? If they just shot joth...why even do that?

For towncred. Isn't it obvious? Kill scum, have them resurrected, be townread for eternity.

And hammer yourself?

[faust]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

If ADK is scum, why did scum target scum? If they just shot joth...why even do that?

For towncred. Isn't it obvious? Kill scum, have them resurrected, be townread for eternity.

And hammer yourself?

I mean, clearly those things aren't connected. Scum just didn't anticipate that mail-mi would out joth. And joth was clearly going down, there was no real reason for him not to hammer. Unless I guess to keep some ambiguity about his alignment. But everyone was already scumreading him.

[MiX]

So scum just prays they win during the day? Yeah okay I can see that I guess.

[WestCoastDidds]

Back to the claiming?

LL
Scola
WCD
MM

[LaLight]

I do see a flaw in your logic: given LaLight's role, it's very much possible that scum!Awaclus had something that makes him townie. Isn't that the whole point of LL's thing? Thus he can be scum.

What do you mean, something that makes him townie? Like he could alignment switch?

Like he could have an ability that when LL checks it looks townie. Because LL exists, everything needs to be worded somewhat townie.

It seems nonsensical to have a scum host with a role that says "you don't count for town's win condition". I don't think abilities would include such pointless fluff just for the sake of LaLight's role.

Yes, I am pretty sure Awaclus was town.

[LaLight]

Doesn't matter that much I suppose. Either way 2 scum are already dead. It's fine actually if you think Awaclus was scum since he pushed me all game, so maybe that will make you townread me.

If ADK is scum, why did scum target scum? If they just shot joth...why even do that?

We're like missing all the pieces. Why does LaLight not have a single incriminating result?

Yes, THAT is a problem. I was thinking I am kind of a modified cop, but so far I wasn't very useful at all.

[LaLight]

Back to the claiming?

LL
Scola
WCD
MM

I already did, I claimed I guessed MiX's ability

[LaLight]

fwiw I know that MiX didn't target himself or mail-mi on Night 5.

[mail-mi]

I agree I think joth is scum, I just don't consider that as outed.

Once reason for scum to kill you as scum is you get your 1 shot powers back. Especially if scum or scum hosts can't kill humans.

But I still can't kill humans. Mail-mi would need to die for that.

Are you human or host?

the fourth ability I guessed was right, and this is MiX's ability, which is called as Roland from Stephen King's Black Tower: he can kill a host every day before the last 48 hours of the day, and if a person dies, the ability is disabled. The text of the ability also tells that when something happens he will be able to kill humans. Doesn't tell which something.

That's my ability. It doesn't just affect scum!hosts, it affects all hosts. Once I die, all hosts can kill humans with killing abilities.

[MiX]

I agree I think joth is scum, I just don't consider that as outed.

Once reason for scum to kill you as scum is you get your 1 shot powers back. Especially if scum or scum hosts can't kill humans.

But I still can't kill humans. Mail-mi would need to die for that.

Are you human or host?

the fourth ability I guessed was right, and this is MiX's ability, which is called as Roland from Stephen King's Black Tower: he can kill a host every day before the last 48 hours of the day, and if a person dies, the ability is disabled. The text of the ability also tells that when something happens he will be able to kill humans. Doesn't tell which something.

That's my ability. It doesn't just affect scum!hosts, it affects all hosts. Once I die, all hosts can kill humans with killing abilities.

This sounds about right. I also confirm that LL's telling the truth, in case that was necessary, that is my ability.

[LaLight]

I agree I think joth is scum, I just don't consider that as outed.

Once reason for scum to kill you as scum is you get your 1 shot powers back. Especially if scum or scum hosts can't kill humans.

But I still can't kill humans. Mail-mi would need to die for that.

Are you human or host?

the fourth ability I guessed was right, and this is MiX's ability, which is called as Roland from Stephen King's Black Tower: he can kill a host every day before the last 48 hours of the day, and if a person dies, the ability is disabled. The text of the ability also tells that when something happens he will be able to kill humans. Doesn't tell which something.

That's my ability. It doesn't just affect scum!hosts, it affects all hosts. Once I die, all hosts can kill humans with killing abilities.

I know. I just tried to articulate MiX's ability as thorough as possible.

[scolapasta]

I'll post more later.

But last night: watched Didds thinking if she is town host, they would try to NK her. (specifically lalight and faust). Got blocked, which faust has confirmed.

Why would you block my watching???

[LaLight]

I'll post more later.

But last night: watched Didds thinking if she is town host, they would try to NK her. (specifically lalight and faust). Got blocked, which faust has confirmed.

Why would you block my watching???

why specifically me and faust?

[faust]

I'll post more later.

But last night: watched Didds thinking if she is town host, they would try to NK her. (specifically lalight and faust). Got blocked, which faust has confirmed.

Why would you block my watching???

Because you're scum. Who do you suggest I should have blocked instead?

[faust]

LaLight, could you restate everything you've learned so far, and who you have targeted each Night?

[LaLight]

LaLight, could you restate everything you've learned so far, and who you have targeted each Night?

oh goodness, should I?

[LaLight]

tried to find where I did that and then remembered I did that in a QT with MiX. Alright then.

[scolapasta]

I'll post more later.

But last night: watched Didds thinking if she is town host, they would try to NK her. (specifically lalight and faust). Got blocked, which faust has confirmed.

Why would you block my watching???

Because you're scum. Who do you suggest I should have blocked instead?

I'm not. Other than PoE, which doesn't seem as useful this game, why do you think this.