Ugh. I quickly reread both of you. Content wise, silver spawn is much scummier than J Reggie. Like, there is almost nothing there besides his claim. J Reggie does some scummy stuff and isn't super active, but more so than silverspawn. My hold up is that there is almost certainly a Roleblocker in the game. Not because scum has been hitting PRs (though that supports the idea), but because of how Jake got caught. Here's the theory:
So here's our scum team:
Cop Enabling 1-shot Psychotrooper [J Reggie or Silverspawn]
Goon OR Flavor Cop [schadd]
1-shot Ninja 2-shot Rolestopper [Jake]
So, we know that Robz was a Watcher. The only way he would know for certain that Jake was scum was if he had watched Space-A and saw that Jake kill them. Now, Mafia cannot kill and use a power in the same night. Jake is clearly the team's most beefed up player. Therefore, to rationalize having Jake commit the kill the other two Mafia members must have a role good enough to use N1. Psychotrooper is awesome, yet predictable N1. If schadd was a Goon, it would make sense that they would have him kill someone. But they don't, implying that he has a PR to use. If he does (aka the Flavor Cop) it would mean that there is a Roleblocker which would mean that silverspawn is Town.
The only other rational explanation is an irrational one. That is, Jake really wanting to be a killer or schadd being a virtual pacifist or something.
What are your (J Reggie and PPS) opinions on this and what conclusions do you draw from it?