Your first point that "If I did" comments are scummy. I disagree. Swowl is one of the two people who read me best. Saying what I would do is based enirely on what I have done. But that is also a belief thing and I won't say anything to change your mind... but you should also recognize it is a belief thing and not based in any evidence of my scum behavior.
I think it is an overstatement or exaggeration. In this game, no one can ignore each other because we are all trying to analyze one another. So maybe as scum, you make the exaggeration because you can lie, whereas as town you know you are not going to be completely able to ignore him. But as scum you are willing to say "I wouldn't do this as scum" when actually you would because you are lying. OK... this is definitely my weakest point of the three and I admit that. And yes I know I don't know your developed meta as well as some other players.
-snip-
Your second point is that no exile is scummy. No, no it is not.
-snip-
Specifically in this RMM I think no exile is a bad thing to advocate for. We know this about the setup: "It will be role madness in that everyone will have a role, but the roles themselves will be mostly uncomplicated and there are no weird novel gimmicks." For that kind of a setup in particular, no exile is bad because we have uncomplicated roles... so the interesting things you claim may happen at night are less likely to happen because this game has been described as basically an RMM lite.
So IMO no exile is bad here and arguing for something bad and then basically only casting one vote and not participating in much scumhunting is scummy.
-snip-
Third point.... I am not mischaracterizing Globble's position. How much he was responsible for the extended discussion of massclaiming, on teh other hand, is arguable and a difference in perception.
-snip-
I disagree that it is a matter of perception. It is measurable. Glooble made exactly three posts, one after another, about the massclaim discussion amounting to a total of 198 words and 1084 characters. Faust has 9 posts on the topic, amounting to 326 words and 1870 characters. Glooble's posts are all responses to faust's and are part of his stated intent of tunneling faust to figure out his alignment. faust's posts are more various and interact with me, e, Glooble, and Awaclus.
Based on these measurements, I cast suspicion on your claim that you reread the massclaim discussion, which you say was a waste of time, and concluded that Glooble came off scummiest in the discussion.