This is mostly about the interactions between the 5 remaining players, minus myself and Axxle, with a bit of "this was kind of suspicious" thrown in. And it's also pretty much all Day 1 stuff, because I haven't gotten around to indexing days 2 and 3. Day 1 took way too long.
General thoughts will be in a follow-up post.
Dsell522: post about everyone. Strong town read on Volt, slight favour for Eevee. Otherwise neutral on pretty much everyone else except for Robz. Interestingly, Dsell is very much against Robz, and in the very next post Volt heavily suspects Robz as well.
546: still find this really weird to say that it's no big deal if 4 townies get killed.
603: calls out O for not saying anything substantial.
626: introduces argument against Eevee for being a pro poker player. Wishy-washy.
688: hedging talk, says he could be persuaded to vote Eevee but doesn't actually suspect him.
Post 843 is kind of interesting. Dsell notes that Robz had said there was a lot of information. Later, Robz died. Maybe Dsell/Mafia feared that Robz really did see something, and would be able to build a strong case?
Eevee214: praises Voltgloss -- "by the way, voltgloss seems to be an awesome guy to have around, really good and insightful posts."
246: after Robz randomly asks Eevee if he's mafia... Eevee doesn't actually deny it.
365: big post on most people; says O is suspicious for weird play (maybe not Mafia, probably not town PR). Says Voltgloss and Dsell seem very town-like:
I'm-pretty-sure-is-town: Voltgloss, Dsell (good, well-argumented posts that strongly make me feel like I can trust you. Either of these being mafia is a scary thought but I can't really see that being the case, it doesnt seem like either is holding any info back).
458: Eevee votes for Robz, quoting an argument from Dsell that Robz' play seems to match his play in MII. Oh, and he calls O a "terrible player".
O459: Vindictively votes for Eevee because of an insult.
578: Questions Voltgloss' strange experiment/analysis.
618: Lists his thoughts on each player. He names several players who he'd like to have on the town side -- CFrisk, Robz, michaeljb, Morgrim. Morgrim was lynched, the rest were NK'd. Also names Dsell and Galz as people who "are close to actively harmful if they were town".
672: Tells jo to switch his vote to Eevee in order to survive (672).
690: Calls out Eevee and Voltgloss who appear to be online but are not saying anything.
Voltgloss197: Cautions against early voting, therefore suspects early voters, which includes Eevee.
523: Strong case against Robz which follows immediately after Dsell's big post that also points FOS at Robz. Votes for Robz.
569: Switches vote from Robz to jotheonah, apparently on the basis of an experiment. Also see post 575. IMO, this "experiment" thing was rather weird and unconvincing. Also interesting to note that Volt says he strongly suspected both jo and Robz, while O said he suspected neither (599).
600: This post references both Dsell and Eevee, with respect to the arguments against Robz:
I should add that, when I ask for a rebuttal from Robz to the points I raised, I do recall he gave a rebuttal to a couple of points. (Not all of them.) Specifically, citing the "weaseling out" that Dsell is supposed to have done (does anyone else agree with Robz that those posts of Dsell's are as suspicious as he sees them?) and apologizing for putting his own words in Eevee's mouth.
I can't tell if he's saying that Dsell is suspicious, or that he's saying Robz is paranoid and Dsell isn't suspicious.
698: expresses concern over the burgeoning Eevee wagon, likening it to the Robz-led Morgrim wagon in MII.
yumaUhh... nothing. I found nothing of significance between yuma and any of the others. Granted, he's been pretty quiet all through this game.