DISCLAIMER: THIS IS ALL ABOUT HUNTING MAQUIS AND NOT SCUM IN GENERAL. BE WARNED.
Okay, here's my attempt at throwing everything I'm using and thinking about to see if others can reach the same conclusions as me. Obviously, I'm assuming I'm town for all of these, so if you replace me with whoever it is you are you'll obtain different information, hopefully they'll converge somewhere. So!
First, the D1 e wagon, essencially boils down to this (green means not Maquis)
2.71828..... (5):
mcmcsalot,
EFHW,
Robz888,
Awaclus, WestCoastDidds
What I've taken from this is that Didds is likely scum. I've been discarding this option because it restricts a lot and Didds was only on it half the time, which diminishes how important this is. But it still exists, so it has to be mentioned. Then the LL(EFHW) wagon, which culminates in:
EFHW (6): Uncleeurope, MiX, WestCoastDidds, UmbrageofSnow,
shraeye,
GloobleBecause I'm town, all I can conclude from this is that I don't think Didds and Snow are Maquisbuddies with shraeye. Maybe there's more things you can say about this wagon that rule out some other scumteams with me on it, but I don't see it. The Uncle vote here's also essencially pointless, since I don't think Maquis would necessarily put 2+ buddies or even 2-. If you think otherwise, state so, but that's all I have to say about this. Now comes Robz's wagon, of course:
Robz888 (10):
2.71828....., WestCoastDidds, UmbrageofSnow,
SpaceAnemone,
chickenwarlord,
DatSwan,
Awaclus,
Glooble,
Jimmmmm, ashersky
From this I took something that will probably be controversial: Didds or Snow is Maquis. I removed ash from the wagon analysis because, as I've said D2, I think D1 wagons have much more information at the early stages and the rest of the votes (all the way from Awaclus, maybe even Swan) were just from people looking to lynch anyone. So, Didds or Snow are Maquis, maybe just ash but I doubt it, I think scum would love to be on the Robz wagon because e was pretty towny and it's incredibly easy to jump on it, as I've said in D2, this wagon's been talked about already. Onto D2! From now on I'm only using end of day wagons, if anyone feels like an intermediate wagon has some relevance, they should speak up NOW. Caps for emphasis.
MiX (4): raerae, ashersky,
shraeye, WestCoastDidds
What a beautiful wagon. There's so much you can pull from it, like, I think there's two Maquis (counting shraeye) in it, but I'm not really using it to make scumteams, maybe I should? The Very Important Information to pull from this is, really, that Didds and ash aren't scum together. I sincerily doubt shraeye and Didds would hop on my wagon as fast as they did (reminder that their votes were after the fast faust wagon stunt in D2) with a scumbuddy on board, I just don't see it happening. It also removes a Didds/raerae scumteam and, to some extent, an ash/raerae scumteam as well, but I believe those are unlikely anyway. Then there's the fact that I could be Maquis, in which case I think it continues to remove a scumteam, in this case Didds/MiX (and maybe ash/MiX), but that's irrelevent to me. With D2 wagons comes the amazing Awaclus wagon:
Awaclus (
:
faust,
Glooble,
DatSwan,
chickenwarlord, Uncleeurope, MiX,
SpaceAnemone,
2.71828.....He was right, his wagon isn't uninformative. This is essencially a big red flag saying that Uncle is scum, or at least that either me or Uncle is scum. This is such a poweful tool for PoE that I have to remove it in other to see anything other than "Uncle is conf!scum". For completion's sake, Snow was on faust, not sure what to make of it. To D3!
2.71828..... (7):
SpaceAnemone, MiX,
faust,
EFHW,
chickenwarlord, UncleEurope, ashersky
chickenwarlord (3):
DatSwan,
2.71828....., WestCoastDidds
MiX (2): raerae, UmbrageOfSnow
I think it was...snow? that said my wagon was also interesting, so all three are useful. I was mostly using the first one, that says that there's probably scum in (MiX/Uncle/ash), but I think it also says there's probably scum in (Didds/Snow/raerae), I think this is a day where scum would split? Especially snow, he essencially has a free pass to townread e and he was inactive, which means I believe that the other scum would be on wagon. Obviously, I'm using it to say that a Snow/Uncle Maquis team is most likely, but what matters is where it comes from.
I think it's coherent to say that the teams are either Uncle/Didds or Uncle/Snow based on this, because it's what I'm extrapolating from all of this, but I think, more than ever, I need everyone's opinion on this. Especially what each maybe-Maquis has to say with a different PoE.
TL;DR: takeaway points from each wagon post, in order: Didds gains scumpoints, Didds/Snow isn't possible, Didds or Snow are Maquis, Didds/ash isn't possible, Uncle is scum(my), Uncle or ash are Maquis; all of this from my PoV, I want feedback on opinions based on other's PoEs. For me it points to Uncle/Didds or Uncle/Snow, therefore Uncle is scum.
I'm going to post my D2 analysis of D1's wagons and will compare to this. Later, hopefully in a few minutes but no promises.