Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

Are you saying Roleblocker can't be town?

[Teproc]

Yeah ok.

vote: iguana

It's not that this is completely incoherent, but his claim is altogether fishy. One-Shot Bulletproof seems too vanilla for this game, it's the only claimed roled that doesn't fit the "typicalPR with some modifier" pattern so far, it sounds like the kind of thing that you would come up with based on a fake flavor claim too.

I don't buy that town!iguana misunderstands what Haddock was talking about earlier.

[Witherweaver]

Yeah ok.

vote: iguana

It's not that this is completely incoherent, but his claim is altogether fishy. One-Shot Bulletproof seems too vanilla for this game, it's the only claimed roled that doesn't fit the "typicalPR with some modifier" pattern so far, it sounds like the kind of thing that you would come up with based on a fake flavor claim too.

I don't buy that town!iguana misunderstands what Haddock was talking about earlier.

But why does scum!Haddock misunderstand it?  What's different in that regard?

[iguanaiguana]

You know there are setups with town rb?

No, I didn't know that.

[iguanaiguana]

Are you saying Roleblocker can't be town?

Yes, apparently I'm wrong?

[Teproc]

scum!iguana you mean ?

iguana said something like "how did you know about the flavor" in response to iguana. Which seems to me like he was trying to appear as if he knew what Haddock was talking about, but didn't... wait, scum!iguana got webbed too, that doesn't work.

Hm. Ok, the whole webbed thing is whatever. Still not a huge fan of the claim, he's part of my lynch pool. Probably prefer the actual VTs at this point though.

vote: Hydrad

Still need to reread some people... going to be tough though, with the holidays.

PPE : Roleblockers are scum slightly more often than town, but overall it's alignment-neutral.

[Haddock]

Huh? WW I don't understand your last post.

Igu case seems weak here, what does igu gain by pretending not to understand what was going on? In any case, probably he did understand, he just didn't want to give too many details out.

PPE. Several.

[Witherweaver]

scum!iguana you mean ?

iguana said something like "how did you know about the flavor" in response to iguana. Which seems to me like he was trying to appear as if he knew what Haddock was talking about, but didn't... wait, scum!iguana got webbed too, that doesn't work.

Hm. Ok, the whole webbed thing is whatever. Still not a huge fan of the claim, he's part of my lynch pool. Probably prefer the actual VTs at this point though.

vote: Hydrad

Still need to reread some people... going to be tough though, with the holidays.

PPE : Roleblockers are scum slightly more often than town, but overall it's alignment-neutral.

Yes, I meant Iguana.  Coming to the conclusion of Jailkeep is suspicious, especially for a new player.  If I was informed I was webbed, I would assume Roleblocked, not Jailkept.  If, say, scum team has a Roleblocker, then this conclusion makes more sense.  Though, he wouldn't have had the opportunity to discuss in the scum QT, since he was informed at the end of the night.

Haddock saying he's a loud Jailkeeper and then Iguana saying "oh, yeah, I knew I was Jailkept!" after the fact is weird.

e got the same thing from Night 1, right?  What did you think?  Also, did you claim?

[Witherweaver]

Huh? WW I don't understand your last post.

Igu case seems weak here, what does igu gain by pretending not to understand what was going on? In any case, probably he did understand, he just didn't want to give too many details out.

PPE. Several.

I mean to say scum!Iguana. 

[Teproc]

Meh. I don't find the Jailkeeper thing particularly significant. And even then it gets back to your earlier point : why is scum!iguana more likely than town!iguana to do that ?

e claimed VT (Captain America). I don't think he confirmed the webbing yet.

[ashersky]

Vote Count 3.4:

EgorK (2): 2.7, Haddock
faust (2): EgorK, Hydrad
Hydrad (1): Teproc

Not Voting (4): Ampharos, WW, faust, iguanaiguana

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day 3 ends at 1:15 p.m. on December 29.

[Witherweaver]

Meh. I don't find the Jailkeeper thing particularly significant. And even then it gets back to your earlier point : why is scum!iguana more likely than town!iguana to do that ?

e claimed VT (Captain America). I don't think he confirmed the webbing yet.

Because maybe scum has a Roleblocker.

[Teproc]

I see. That's a good point. Still prefer Hydrad I think.

[iguanaiguana]

People are talking about how everything I've been saying is a mess. I agree. All I can say is that the reason is not-alignment related, but due to the fact that I've been very rushed trying to make posts, then get back to either my family, or driving, or packing, or unpacking, etc.

I am sorry if town ends up with another mislynch today because I have been rushing through my posts : /

[Haddock]

e claimed VT (Captain America). I don't think he confirmed the webbing yet.

Captain America

VT

I was webbed N1

[Haddock]

Meh. I don't find the Jailkeeper thing particularly significant. And even then it gets back to your earlier point : why is scum!iguana more likely than town!iguana to do that ?

e claimed VT (Captain America). I don't think he confirmed the webbing yet.

Because maybe scum has a Roleblocker.

Roleblocker, vanillaiser and redirection seems severely unlikely.  We have no evidence for rb at all.
Admittedly igu could be making up the vanillaising, and redirection isnt confirmed, but still more for those than for an rb.

[Haddock]

I still like egor here. Annoyed at myself for backing off yesterday.

Amph, havent heard from you in a while.

[Ampharos]

Sorry, all caught up.  Been busy with the holidays and such. 

I'll admit that iguana is not as solid of town as I previously believed him to be.  But I don't think that's where we look today.  I still like the VT lynch.  EgorK didn't go through on our first try, but I'm not sure if that's because he is or isn't scum.  I did really think he was town earlier and am not sure if I'm ready to toss that in the trash just yet. 

All that said, we've got some time, and as I'm not sure who to lynch yet, I'm going to hold off voting right now.  I'll do a full think-through when I have a little more time.

[Witherweaver]

Vote: Teproc

[Witherweaver]

Why cop e instead of me or Faust?

[Teproc]

I thoughg you were town and faust was relatively likely to be NKed. I also thought e was scum, and scum results are much, much better than town results.

[Haddock]

I thoughg you were town and faust was relatively likely to be NKed. I also thought e was scum, and scum results are much, much better than town results.

I actually think this is pretty weak. It hadn't occurred to me that Faust and ww were obvious cop targets.  Admittedly my jk targets haven't worked out great, but I don't see any convincing reason why I wouldn't have copped one of the two claimed investigators here.
Scum might well have known that claiming a town result on one of Faust and ww would have looked too suspicious here, encouraging teproc to claim the way he did.

[Hydrad]

Vote: egork

[2.71828.....]

Sorry things are super busy. I totally believe teproc. No way he backs off me the way he does without hard evidence

[2.71828.....]

He would not do that as scum. I was preparing myself to fight tooth and nail for survival worth teproc as my main "opponent."