If anybody can come up with a system that allows us to make all 4 kills (7 Alive, 2 IC's + Vig = 3, meaning 4 unknown players left), feel free to post it. I don't think it can be done (I think the maximum we can get is 3 - and there's a lot of different ways for that to happen), but I'm still all ears. I didn't think HP could be solved until it suddenly struck me, so, maybe I've missed something.
On that note, even after Chairs has cleared Eevee as well, don't hammer out to no-lynch right away. I'm willing to let this stall for a few hours to give everybody a chance to think everything over, look back, etc.
Eevee: I'm debating this, but do you think it would be worthwhile for each player to post a list (no reasons need to be given, so we don't tip anything) of the remaining 4 players from scummiest to towniest?
Scum-v-
A
B
C
D
Town-^-
We had have 5 lists posted, only one of which would be by scum. This would give our Vigilante an idea of where people stand. He knows who he is already, which means he's just looking at the 4 other lists (3 by town, 1 by scum), but he'll at least have an idea of where the town opinion is (knowing that 3/4 aren't trying to mislead him, even if he doesn't know who is who). Plus, if the Vig does shoot town, it'll give us another set of credible reads to look back on tomorrow.
I don't think we'll be concerned about tipping off where our Vig is if we do it this way, and even if somehow we do, and scum kill the Vig tonight, we're still left with 5 alive tomorrow, with both you and myself around (So two more lynches, out of 3 players).