You can disagree with me, but I just got done being scum in a game, and I think scum benefits a lot more from knowing they won't be lynched without a ton of warning and a lot of hemming and hawing. All that said, I'm not going to derphammer anybody on purpose. I'm town, I'll play nice.
Town has this tendency day 1 to run up a wagon, run it down, analyze it and then lynch someone else. And that's kind of fine, I guess, but it means that if scum manages to be the first big wagon of the day, they almost get a town pass. I'd rather not see that happen to Ichimaru, because I still think he's scum.
Ichi, it's not like the case on you is rock solid. But it's a totally fine day 1 case. You're behaving exactly how I expect caught scum to behave. And yeah, maybe that's confirmation bias or whatever, but I'm my gut is still saying you're scum. And unless we manage to put together a better case than that, that's where I'd like to be.
I also hate day 1 and am a big fan of getting it over with as quickly as possible. So, I'm not for sure locked in but vote: Ichimaru until someone convinces me otherwise.