701
Variants and Fan Cards / Re: New Dominion Cards by... Me!!!! :D
« on: November 27, 2013, 07:37:55 pm »Chapel is an exceptional case.
Lookout is not cantrip. The +1 card matters a lot. Moreover, it gives you far reduced selection (3 cards instead of your hand) and it gets very dangerous to play in the mid game.
Loan is a copper, which is not at all like a cantrip. And it only trashes treasures. If you buy any other Treasures it will start to whiff (hitting your Silvers and Golds) quite a lot.
Lookout doesn't have +1 Card, but since it trashes from deck instead of hand, it keeps your handsize the same as a cantrip trasher would do, so it seems equivalent to a (nerfed) cantrip trasher to me. The same holds for Loan, which neither costs an action nor decreases handsize any more than Junk Dealer does. (If the top card of my deck is a Copper, playing Junk Dealer to trash a Copper and playing Loan actually do exactly the same thing, both for my current term and for my deck content.)
Of course both cards have the substantial nerfs that you mention, but they also have the advantage of mild filtering resp. giving $1 over a "vanilla" cantrip trasher.
The question is if Lookout and Loan are so weak only because of these nerfs, or if a cantrip trasher isn't that strong to begin with.