In other news, I've been re-reading Eddie. He really jumps around a lot, and makes a lot of votes without stating any sort of case. A few times I think I'm confused in my re-read because he also uses quotes very rarely so it's often necessary to dig back a bit with each post to see who he might be responding to. It seems to lead to a very un-auditable vote reasoning trail, which I think is something scum benefits from more than town.
These are the only people alive in the game who Eddie has notvoted for, though WCD, Ash, e and raerae are people he has professed to have a scumread or general suspicion on at least once in this game: DatSwan, WestCoastDidds, Shraeye, ashersky, 2.71828....., raerae
I'd have to re-do my re-read in order to check whether he's said a single thing about Shraeye. He did at least have a small tangle with Swan over the Gul Dukat claim and Swan's confusion over the godfather/miller distinction.
Anyway, I would not be averse to voting him, though can people who've played with him before please clarify whether he throws around quite so many scumreads and unaccounted votes in his usual town game, as he claims? One other thing I found mildly suspicious is that he asks WCD to give reasons why he's not on her radar at #1070, which seems a lot like fishing for a towncase to be made on him. He's done an awful lot of throwing suspicion all game, voting for one person while saying that things by two or three others are scummy, which seems to be probing where town are more or less willing to vote rather than trying to make cases on people for actually being scummy.
So I'll go with Vote: Eddie for now.
Deadline is lunch o'clock tomorrow, so that's accessible to me. If the Eddie wagon doesn't take off, or if enough people persuade me that this is just his normal town playstyle, then I'll be happy to move my vote back to the Awaclus wagon, or to see what else springs up overnight. I'm less happy with the faust one because if he's still alive D3 he'll have even more game stat analysis to help with, and yet won't be able to afford not to be totally pro-town about it.