1
Mafia Game Threads / Re: RMM61: Battlestar Galactica - Season 2 (Day 1)
« on: June 23, 2021, 03:11:40 pm »vote: ADK
I feel like this is a better place for my vote.
Why?
vote: ADK
I feel like this is a better place for my vote.
Because I really can't imagine a game where we could win if we literally sit around and do nothing.
OK, here's a genuine reason not to vote for me: I can keep an eye on what the President is doing with the quorum.
Yes, and I would've hammered you if we were both at X-1 too. That doesn't mean you didn't go "hey btw mix is double hated so just vote for him and win". It seemed that, between a win and a win, you were favouring town. And that's exactly what town needed from you.
MiX, how much was your personal goal affecting your play?
Too much, but I also grouped in the fact that I got passive information that was probably going to scale in usefulness, so I was valuing my life very highly. I also had the information that ADK claimed third-party, which I felt was important for town to have.You were certain ADK was playing for town, but they weren't.If ADK hadn't self voted, we might still have exiled Jack or Dylan. Guess that's why ash is saying exile all 3rd parties.
ADK can't self-hammer if you don't vote for them. That's why I didn't want to vote for them lol.
Besides, scum can hammer too.
What needed to happen was a quickhammer on scum by town. Unfortunately, that feat is basically impossible, and was never going to happen with how fragmented town was.
They could've just voted for me last day if they wanted to play for scum. Maybe their true win condition didn't allow for that, but what they claimed to me did. The fact they still voted Dylan showed their loyalty.
@scola -- I don't know how you could have recruited me; I assumed the team knew.
@ADK -- you can switch characters and then not worry about the legacy stuff.
That was fun. Not the best outcome for me, I lost out on some legacy points, but it was interesting to play such an odd win conditionFor legacy reasons, l'll keep it a mystery
Keep what a mystery? The rule changes? I'm fairly sure those would have to be public.
I was talking about mix's question about my legacy points
So just to understand, you were not actually a Survivor? But you haven't (and won't) reveal what it was?
I could say what alignment ADK had, they told me that much. But isn't it cooler if it's mysterious instead?
I'm looking at Day 1 plurality exile and the admiral role as changes
Agree on both.
I like the admiral change, but not plurality exile. I never see that as good for town. How about adding another player?
I'm curious how mafia got 3 NKs in one night. Seems...hard to defeat.
Scola played the best of the mafia-aligned players, in my opinion, although MiX definitely should be MVP for ensuring their win.
For legacy reasons, l'll keep it a mystery
Keep what a mystery? The rule changes? I'm fairly sure those would have to be public.