Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[jotheonah]

I'm going to Vote: Voltaire

1) I'd love a real flip
2) The speed at which he went from voting xeiron to voting me based on a point xeiron made is a little dizzying. If you're ready to lynch someone, why would you let them tell you who to lynch and why.
3) There's scum on my wagon. Look at the way I suddenly became a target AFTER my dayvig was gone -- scum was scared to vote for me when I could shoot them in response, came out of the woodwork when it was safe.

[EFHW]

Vote Count 2.11efhw

faust (1): Walrus
joth (1): faust
EFHW (1): Archetype
Walrus (1): EFHW
xeiron (1): jotheonah
jotheonah (2): Voltaire, xeiron

Not Voting (0)

It takes 4 to lynch.  Deadline in 1 hr 23 minutes

[EFHW]

Vote Count 2.11efhw.2

faust (1): Walrus
joth (1): faust
EFHW (1): Archetype
Walrus (1): EFHW
Voltaire (1): jotheonah
jotheonah (2): Voltaire, xeiron

Not Voting (0)

It takes 4 to lynch.  Deadline in 1 hr 23 minutes

[EFHW]

I'm astonished Voltaire just left with us in this state, not making a bit of noise about it.

[EFHW]

Who is on? 

[jotheonah]

Vote Count 2.11efhw

faust (1): Walrus
EFHW (1): Archetype
Walrus (1): EFHW
Voltaire (1): jotheonah
jotheonah (3): Voltaire, xeiron, faust

Not Voting (0)

It takes 4 to lynch.  Deadline in 1 hr 23 minutes

FTFY

Ok, who wants to help me lynch Voltaire? we have an hor and I need to get on a plane in 20 m.

[EFHW]

Just noticed you are on there twice.  L-1

Vote Count 2.11efhw.3

faust (1): Walrus
EFHW (1): Archetype
Walrus (1): EFHW
Voltaire (1): jotheonah
jotheonah (3): faust, Voltaire, xeiron {L-1}

Not Voting (0)

It takes 4 to lynch.  Deadline in 1 hr 20 minutes

[EFHW]

So now I am also astonished xeiron and Voltaire put joth at L-1 without saying anything.

[jotheonah]

xeiron did say it was L1

[EFHW]

Walrus are you still there?  If it's just the 3 of us, we can only lynch Joth or me.  But I'm not going to self-vote.

[EFHW]

xeiron did say it was L1

ok then

[EFHW]

joth what is the case against you and what is your response?

[xeiron]

I am nearby, and will take a look on the game once in a while. But I will probably not stay all the time until deadline.

[EFHW]

can you summarize why you are voting for joth?

[Archetype]

I'm here. Anyone want to vote EFHW?

[EFHW]

what's your case?

[WalrusMcFishSr]

I'm here. But only intermittently.

Are those really our only options? What happens again if there's no majority? Does the most popular wagon get it, or is it an automatic no lynch, or random, or what?

[xeiron]

I'm here. But only intermittently.

Are those really our only options? What happens again if there's no majority? Does the most popular wagon get it, or is it an automatic no lynch, or random, or what?

I could not find anything in the rules specifying if there is a no lynch, or the most popular wagon goes through.
That point have probably fallen out of the rulestet somwhere in the process of copy-pasting-from-game-to-game.
I assume no-lynch.

[xeiron]

I'm here. Anyone want to vote EFHW?

Not really.
What is wrong with Jotheonah?

[xeiron]

can you summarize why you are voting for joth?

I assume that was a question for me.
I am not rewriting the case, but I can pull up the relevant quotes.

resons to vote for Jotheonah:

- He was my top scumread after D1 as explained a earlier post.

vote: Jotheonah.
He have been trying to spread doubt about players;

Not sure what to make of this at all. My gut reaction is to not believe ashersky, but I'm not all about gut reactions. Nonetheless, my conclusion about early ash semi-claims is not to act on them one way or another. No town cred, etc. Whatever scum!ash might have hoped to gain from the claim, we should be careful not to offer. If ash does anything to earn town cred down the line, maybe we give some more weight to the claim.

Not a fan of the day 1 mass claim, as per usual.

is it weird that Eevee is defending Ash's claim and Ash is nowhere to be seen?

Works for whom, that's the question.

And he have proposed lynches that is not really the best for eliminating scum.

You know what,

Vote:ashersky

Last game, he claimed off the bat, got town cred for it, and survived off that cred until the end of the game -- despite many people voicing concerns over his towniness. The fact is, FoSes without votes are just fine for scum.

Let's try lynching him this time! Even if he's town, at least we're not losing a useful power role.

Hey EFHW, your power is negative utility? Do you want a new one? We could lynch you! And test the everyone has two lives theory.

In general, it seems to me like Jotheonah is looking for reasons to lynch people, not looking for scum.

- He is a vig (dayvig, true, but still a vig) and we already have a confirmed town vig in Ashersky.
I have more beliefe in one town and one scum vig, than two town vigs.


resons not to vote Jotheonah

- From the top of my head, his actions D2 has been pretty towny.

+

it looks like if Eevee does come back to life, it won't be until tomorrow. Guess the next thing is to look back at his posts and see if they yield any insights.

Another point against Jotheonah is this post.
It is almost as if he knows Eevees alignment, and forgot that the rest of us don't as eevee's alligment was not revealed in the flip.

Scumslip?

[yuma]

Vote Count 2.12

faust (1): Walrus
joth (3): Faust, voltaire, xeiron
EFHW (1): arch
Walrus (1): EFHW
Voltaire (1): joth

Not Voting (0):

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline for Day2 is 8 days and will be February 14 at 8 pm forum time.

[xeiron]

Mod question:
What happens if there's no majority for any lynch at deadline? Does the most popular wagon get it, or is it an automatic no lynch, or random, or what?

[yuma]

Mod question:
What happens if there's no majority for any lynch at deadline? Does the most popular wagon get it, or is it an automatic no lynch, or random, or what?

A no lynch

[EFHW]

If it's our only option, I'll hammer joth.  But I don't think there is much of a case against him.  We don't have a good case against anyone, really, though.

[Archetype]

I'm here. Anyone want to vote EFHW?

Not really.
What is wrong with Jotheonah?

Nothing, I suppose. I just prefer EFHW. Her role is really, really weird and I see 0 Town benefit. I can hammer if-needed.