I'm here! Not for long, cos bed. Sorry.
unvote to start with, Lalight looking much better of late I think.
Sorry not to tell people I would be missing so much of this.
oh my golly my gosh this is like my new favorite picture
Ugh. Don't like this stuff from schadd. Reads like forced humour.
Roadrunner7671 I'm not lynching RR D1 again unless he scumslips hard or something.
silverspawn not much useful content. A good D1 lynch.
LaLight something made me think he was scum. I think he feels a lot like he did in ghibli.
schadd hard to read as always. Maybe more likely to be scum, but I don't have any completed games with him where I was town.
pingpongsam more likely town because of his stunt, but he hasn't had to "prove his commitment" yet.
JaketheBaseballGod22 weird and hard to read. Another good reason not to lynch newbies D1 besides not getting the hang of things is because one has no idea how to read them
Fargo if it was every right to lynch an IC it would be Fargo. But I won't go that far (see what I did there?)
mail-mi the mod. Wouldn't lynch.
Calamitas can't find anything of note from him. Would lynch.
SpaceAnenome scary as scum. Would lynch if the opportunity presented itself. Although maybe they'll follow my pattern and be extremely good in their first scum game and fall apart after that.
J Reggie IC. Wouldn't lynch.
Robz888 nearly nothing useful, which is a shame. I was looking forward to playing with Robz.
Haddock a good player. He out-towned me after being conf!scum. Would Lynch.
McGarnacle nothing of note. Seems different from NM so quite possibly scum. He's flying under the radar more. But then again he did nearly get lynched D1 there so he has a reason to try something different. Not sure.
RR - agree
silver - hurr. Without a case, lynching silver D1 seems meh. He's too good a town player.
Lalight - increasingly disagreeing of late
schadd - sure. Don't disagree
PPS - OK.
Jake - 100% agree with this
Calamitas - yep.
Space - Ok sure, that's not really a position but Space is not a good lynch for today, anyway.
Robz - Burn. Disagree.
Haddock - dealt with this already
McGarnacle - Definitely with you on that. McGarnacle edging towards the top of my scumreads.
If we don't reach a majority, we will lose a lynch. Therefore we shouldn't be really picky with our lynch, as scummy as that may sound. I'm willing to go anywhere, but I have a weak preference of Jake over LaLight. So I will vote: Jake . It doesn't make sense to widen the lynchpool more since it is unlikely that we find enough votes to lynch someone that is not in {Jake, LaLight}. So please restrict yourself to that pool, no lynch would be the worst thing to happen.
Ewwwwww.
Yeah LaLight that's not the best idea. Or towniest idea
Very forced. Man I so want to lynch RR here.
I am not scum.
Whatever.
Will kill the nice side of me.
vote: Jake
Sad.
That's a huge turn, before you even preferred lynching yourself.
Really not. Noone actually expected Lalight to mean that, he was just making a point. Opportunistic from Calamitas.
I am not scum.
Whatever.
Will kill the nice side of me.
vote: Jake
Sad.
That's a huge turn, before you even preferred lynching yourself.
Whatever, man.
It's a game after all, not psychologically social training
If your not scum give us your case of why we should not lynch you
Prove that you are town
Welcome back, Awaclus.
sure.
vote: calamitas
i would say that i suspect pps and rr most, about the same amount, and calamitas a little bit less (i wasn't lying before, but yeah this last part has seemed a bit sketch). all 3 of these are better than no lynch for me, though, thus i will vote wherever a vote matters the most (which is to say, if any of these three get momentum)
Nyerf. Don't like this much at all.
First of all, forgetting the IC doesn't mean much here in case of a newbie. It hasn't been declared before D1 so scum will not have discussed it (I am neglecting the chance of having a day chat here).
And I do actually think that having a no lynch D1 is worse than having a townie lynched. So I would be willing to get myself lynched over having a no lynch. Though I obviously prefer other outcomes since I have a chance of hitting scum there, I don't view my own death as a more negative utility than having a no lynch. And since I know I would think that as town and have expressed it as town before I would probably pull that as scum anyways because it comes closest to my town behavior. That's why you shouldn't read much into it except that I am, if the situation requires it, willing to go to bed with a vote on me.
This could actually legit come from a towny I think. It's a weird extension of a common belief. Feels right. Some rare townpoints here.
tl;dr
OK, so I'm totally fine with a Calamitas lynch. Right now my top scumreads are something like:
RR > McGarnacle = schadd > Calamitas > Reggie
But I don't
actually want to lynch RR because he's too easy to mislynch.
McGarnacle and schadd I'd prefer to Calamitas, but don't see that happening.
vote: Calamitas