I'd say that the way that chairs reacted to the whole thing absolutely speaks to his alignment, and that he's scummy as hell. Especially voting for ash after I said I would have found OMGUS to be a towny reaction.
I agree, and it's basically the only actual information we have at this point. Except for Seprix putting Ashersky on L-1, which I still think could be a newbie error. Therefore, Vote: chairs.
Faust, this is how. Especially voting for ashersky (reply #99), which put him to L-2.
Before someone argues "you voted for ashersky too", I did, but at the time, it seemed like 1 of us was scum (due to the Yule Ham thing), so my vote made sense, also it put him at like L-3 or L-4, which is safe. Chairs' vote didn't from a town point of view, seems like he may have wanted a quick lynch. He hasn't done anything else
Also, I'm not 100% convinced by chairs voting himself. I did it as town in M53, but it seemed to cause me more trouble than help. Still thinking it could be a double-bluff (although this part of the evidence is weak).
PPE: I know some of this overlaps with what ADK has just written, he posted whilst i was writing, and I agree.
My lynch pool (in no particular order):
A Drowned Kernel - posts seem towny, he warned us about Ashersky being L-1.
Joseph2302- me
faust - looks to me wanting more information/discussion, which is a good town thing.
Awaclus - activity enough to seem townie
silverspawn - not sure why he's voting for me, not getting a town read on him
sudgy - not enough posts to get real sense
Witherweaver - some posts, not getting a real scum sense from them.
Hydrad - not many posts, lurky scum perhaps?
EgorK - not many posts, lurky scum perhaps?
chairs - see above
Seprix - his questions seem genuine newbie, and not scum hiding. Ashersky L-1 seems like a newbie mistake.
Ashersky - ashersky seems pretty townie
Author
Topic: M55: Mafia Holiday! - Town Wins! (Read 102245 times)