WW, Lalight: townie.
J Reggie: slightly scummy, though he seems like the type of guy that gets scumread as town every game.
schadd seems very schadd-y. Is this his first game?
J Reggie is bad for suggesting a claim. WW is baaaaad for suggesting a flavor claim.
Joseph was RVSing too far into day 1. slightly scummy.
J Reggie/faust exchange seems like one of them could very well be scum. doesn't seem like town v town to me. Could even be scum v scum. Will look at more if one of them flips scum.
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.
I'm gonna do a line by line.
agree with LaLight being townie, but it scares me that he is pretty universally a town read. Not so sure about WW. He is pretty null to me
Yes it is his first game
I don't think suggesting claims is all that bad. It wasn't very clear that all the VTs had the same flavor name.
Again, this is just Joseph being Joseph
What in their exchange makes you think it isn't town/town?
It's not all that bad, but it's still bad. Could have been town!WW or scum!WW not reading the set up, or scum!WW banking on lots of us not reading the set up. Both are about equally likely, so then it's more likely that he's scum in my mind right now.
It seems more likely that it's scum v scum than town v town. An early D1 bus that will never go anywhere except to maybe get some town credit, and faust's response seems wrong. Not sure about town v scum yet.
actually, i've just talked myself into it. JR also suggested a D1 claim.
vote: J Reggie