So, since I muddied the waters based on bad mod-supplied info. I'll try to clarify again:
Haddock and Lalight are both claiming to use the blue lift within 1 action of each other. 1 of them must be lying.
Reasons to believe Lalight (as far as I can tell):
-Haddock claimed first. Lalight's claim unnecessarily contradicted Haddock's claim, which gives us a 1-for-1 trade. Scum would not normally do this.
-Lalight does appear to have used the Doctor power (since we know a doctor power was used and no one else claimed it, there was also an unclaimed Tracker power used, and 2 people have claimed that Skumpy stayed in white, so Tracker is much likelier than Doctor for him)
-Haddock always claimed after silver to have done the same things. (D2 he claimed blocked weak visitor after silver, D3 he claimed "I did the same thing" after Silver. In spite of what e says, I find this to be alignment indicative as it is easier to lie by claiming "I did the same" then come up with legitimate townie actions)
Reasons to believe Haddock (IMO):
-He didn't exactly claim his actions, so it could be that Lalight did not realize he was contradicting Haddock. Lalight seems to be somewhat uncertain about stuff (i.e. not realizing he was last to claim), so it is feasible that he didn't put enough effort into his fake claim to avoid the contradiction.
-He sounds more reasonable.
I do not believe that anyone else's claims enter into this conflict at this point. Haddock talks a good game IMO, but the facts favor Lalight, so I think I'm going back to vote: Haddock.
I would like to hear what caused the error in my qt...but I don't think it's actually relevant to anything. I apologize for all the confusion.
@faust: if Haddock ends up town, there's the four of us you have slotted for filling central. Any opinion of what we should do if we're not the designated central-energy filler?