Sorry guys for being absent, I've been on vacation. I am way behind and slowly working my way back up... Here's a few thoughts I have through page 38. I'm going to continue reading the last 10 pages to catch up (I was like 25 behind... why such the talkative D1? Kinda a pain to read...) So I'll vote when I catch the rest of the way up, but I want to post what my thoughts are thus far.:
Eevee: He's looking pretty scummy to me. Why?
-He asks Mail-mi why he (mm) has a scum read on eevee
-The instructions on how to read him. To me, it looks like he's trying to WIFOM us, and I really don't like it.
-around post#599, ash and eevee were basically saying they found eachother towny. Ash was saying that if eevee is scum, he's playing scum badly, and eevee says he thinks ash is town. The whole interaction between them doesn't sit well with me. Just feels too convenient that they make up and see eachother as town after ash tunneled eevee (I think that's what happened, I should have written this down right when I thought of it)
nkirbit:
-I don't give towncred to calling out your post like eevee did, like others later, I think it was a good way to direct scum to information in the post. You say that you couls just tell them tonight in the scum QT, but what if the information is useful now? what if you want to direct scum into setting up a mislynch on me? I don't buy it as a towny move.
-Overall, I can't make a decision on nkirbit this game. In mean girls, it was pretty obvious that he was town. Here, not so much. Granted, earlier he stated that he wasn't as interested in this game due to another one, but still, Something feels different about him here.
Xerion:
EFHW:
I'm pretty convinced by the scumslip that ash points out. Previously, it had been mentioned that stealing items could be possible, but nobody said that it was something that actually exists in this game. EFHW seems to think that the combinations scum can make will cause them to steal items, and I don't see anything that would make EFHW think that this is something scum can get. Or something that scum doesn't already have. Just seems like he has information the rest of town doesn't.
Mail-mi:
-He looks scummy, like others have said. Few, short posts. Not very meaty. But I like his re-read of xerion. Doesn't give him towncred or scumcred. I agree with others on it, I don't think I need to reiterate what others have said about it. Also, this looks like town mail-mi, if mean girls was any indication
Spiritbears:
-Still see him as a big scum read. He still hasn't answered me from earlier, except his apology.
PPE: so 118 new posts... but I still want to get these thoughts out there so I have some reads down before the soft deadline (I just hope it's not already decided). Sorry, vacation makes it hard to keep up with mafia.