Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[jotheonah]

could the team really be Robz, scotty, ADK?

[Robz888]

could the team really be Robz, scotty, ADK?

Nope.

[Voltaire]

FINALLY getting to the yuma/Teproc/Voltaire trifecta of town-v-town-v-town. Let's see how everyone reacted to that!

[Voltaire]

Have we gotten anything from Scott or ADK yet?

relevant to joth

[Robz888]

FINALLY getting to the yuma/Teproc/Voltaire trifecta of town-v-town-v-town. Let's see how everyone reacted to that!

I reacted by calling it as town/town/town!!

[Robz888]

Just did speed re-read paying close attention to Axxle. It's Axxle. He voted consistently to avoid an ADK lynch. Vote: Axxle

Mail-mi, Joth very unlikely to be partners.

XP looks pretty bad.

[jotheonah]

It looks to me right now like we're looking at either the Robz-scotty-ADK team or the Axxle-XP-ADK team.

Even if I've called a team correctly though, there's still almost certainly an SK out there and if it takes us two more nights to lynch scum that's a lot of dead town.

I have absolutely no lead on who the SK might be.

[jotheonah]

I think that SK-hunting will be the focus of my re-read tonight.

[Voltaire]

Just did speed re-read paying close attention to Axxle. It's Axxle. He voted consistently to avoid an ADK lynch. Vote: Axxle

Mail-mi, Joth very unlikely to be partners.

XP looks pretty bad.

Can you explain lines 2 and 3?

[Voltaire]

In fact, sure. Vote: Jotheonah

The first time Robz moves away from ADK. ADK was at four votes.

[mail-mi]

Sudgy could be scum, but we have so many other better choices thatl I'm not even going to consider lynching him today.

Meanwhile,  I think that Vote: Axxle is a good plan.

[Voltaire]

request vote count

[Voltaire]

I think I want to vote for Scotty. Vote: Scott Pilgrim

He's sort of lurky and his contributions read scummy to me. Forced, maybe.

But Robz started the SP wagon.

joth, I want your reactions to this.

[theorel]

It looks to me right now like we're looking at either the Robz-scotty-ADK team or the Axxle-XP-ADK team.

Even if I've called a team correctly though, there's still almost certainly an SK out there and if it takes us two more nights to lynch scum that's a lot of dead town.

I have absolutely no lead on who the SK might be.

Why not ashersky? Am I missing something? (also, not that I mind, but why not me?)

[Robz888]

Just did speed re-read paying close attention to Axxle. It's Axxle. He voted consistently to avoid an ADK lynch. Vote: Axxle

Mail-mi, Joth very unlikely to be partners.

XP looks pretty bad.

Can you explain lines 2 and 3?

Very unlikely to be partners to ADK, is what I meant. I base that on their strong, concerted effort to move the lynch to ADK at games end. His lynch was by no means guaranteed. They made it happen. Axxle, on the other hand, tried to distract from it, though he tried to be in favor of it at other times.

XP's post hammer attempt at hammer is scummy, to me.

[Robz888]

I think I want to vote for Scotty. Vote: Scott Pilgrim

He's sort of lurky and his contributions read scummy to me. Forced, maybe.

But Robz started the SP wagon.

joth, I want your reactions to this.

I think it's perfectly plausible that I, as scum, would start a wagon on Scotty, my partner, and expect it to fizzle out. That's how I would defend Joth's argument for the Robz/Scotty/ADK team, which is nevertheless false, of course.

[Voltaire]

Gotcha. I thought you meant mail-mi and joth couldn't be partners with each other. I haven't read the end of D1 yet but I assume you're right.

[Robz888]

It looks to me right now like we're looking at either the Robz-scotty-ADK team or the Axxle-XP-ADK team.

Even if I've called a team correctly though, there's still almost certainly an SK out there and if it takes us two more nights to lynch scum that's a lot of dead town.

I have absolutely no lead on who the SK might be.

Why not ashersky? Am I missing something? (also, not that I mind, but why not me?)

I think you're both on a mid tier of suspects, below Axxle and XP.

[theorel]

It looks to me right now like we're looking at either the Robz-scotty-ADK team or the Axxle-XP-ADK team.

Even if I've called a team correctly though, there's still almost certainly an SK out there and if it takes us two more nights to lynch scum that's a lot of dead town.

I have absolutely no lead on who the SK might be.

Why not ashersky? Am I missing something? (also, not that I mind, but why not me?)

I think you're both on a mid tier of suspects, below Axxle and XP.

But why?  That's what I'm asking...
Why is ashersky townier than Axxle?  I find him scummier, because his play this game is so subdued, and subdued-ash tends to be scum-ash.
Axxle's play this game just seems like regular Axxle play.  I mean, yes he's scummy for redirecting to scott, but ash did it too.
Heck, I did it, I must have said 3 or 4 times, that I just didn't find ADK all that scummy.
So, what I'm looking for is what Axxle did specifically that's making him scummier?

(I get XP with the post-hammer hammer thing, although I make him slightly townier because of it)

[Robz888]

If you re-read Axxle's posts and voting history with the knowledge that ADK is scum, I think he looks much worse than ashersky.

Also, I don't think that muted ash is scum ash. Ash has been just as insane as scum in recent games, let me tell you, sir.

I don't know what to make of ashersky, except he's had very real VLAs that I think are a better explanation of his relatively quiet attitude, rather than his alignment.

[jotheonah]

Robz is saying all the stuff I was going to say in response to other people's questions.

I think it's perfectly plausible that I, as scum, would start a wagon on Scotty, my partner, and expect it to fizzle out. That's how I would defend Joth's argument for the Robz/Scotty/ADK team, which is nevertheless false, of course.

If you re-read Axxle's posts and voting history with the knowledge that ADK is scum, I think he looks much worse than ashersky.

Also, I don't think that muted ash is scum ash. Ash has been just as insane as scum in recent games, let me tell you, sir.

I don't know what to make of ashersky, except he's had very real VLAs that I think are a better explanation of his relatively quiet attitude, rather than his alignment.

[Voltaire]

Vote: ADK

This is L-1.

I tried bussing my partner, I really did. But if you're going to give me a mislynch I'm fine with it.

Robz, your explanation for this? Partner giving up?

[jotheonah]

It looks to me right now like we're looking at either the Robz-scotty-ADK team or the Axxle-XP-ADK team.

Even if I've called a team correctly though, there's still almost certainly an SK out there and if it takes us two more nights to lynch scum that's a lot of dead town.

I have absolutely no lead on who the SK might be.

Why not ashersky? Am I missing something? (also, not that I mind, but why not me?)

I think you're both on a mid tier of suspects, below Axxle and XP.

But why?  That's what I'm asking...
Why is ashersky townier than Axxle?  I find him scummier, because his play this game is so subdued, and subdued-ash tends to be scum-ash.
Axxle's play this game just seems like regular Axxle play.  I mean, yes he's scummy for redirecting to scott, but ash did it too.
Heck, I did it, I must have said 3 or 4 times, that I just didn't find ADK all that scummy.
So, what I'm looking for is what Axxle did specifically that's making him scummier?

(I get XP with the post-hammer hammer thing, although I make him slightly townier because of it)

Just re-read the end of the day. Axxle doesn't just vote scotty, he does it several times. He keeps checking in, like he's antsy. He switches to mail-mi. He switches right back to Scott.

You're right, it could be ashersky or you, but Axxle fits the profile.

[Voltaire]

I see Robz as a darn good candidate myself right now. In addition to things everyone else is saying.

[jotheonah]

Vote: ADK

This is L-1.

I tried bussing my partner, I really did. But if you're going to give me a mislynch I'm fine with it.

Robz, your explanation for this? Partner giving up?

Man, I did not see that. That does make Axxle look a little better.