Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[yuma]

every day

[yuma]

MiX before ash

Best reason? (Say it’s the hat eating, say it’s the hat eating!)

hat eating

[yuma]

and also ash just seems super town

[yuma]

like not what he is done, but how he is acting

[Swowl]

well shit. looks like a "sorry yuma" is gonna be due... it was great to play with you though.

[WestCoastDidds]

every day

Well, anything goes on Snathurday. Everyone know this.

[yuma]

well shit. looks like a "sorry yuma" is gonna be due... it was great to play with you though.

IT was fun. WE should do it again.

[scolapasta]

So you're saying you were two?

Gah, I thought as much.

Swan I look forward to hearing your idea "tomorrow". I think I might have a guess at what it could be, though I'm probably completely off.

[A Drowned Kernel]

yuma was lynched! He was a Vanilla Townie

Final Vote Count

MiX (2): ashersky, yuma
ashersky (1): MiX
yuma (4): WestCoastDidds, Dylan32, DatSwan, scolapasta

With 7 alive it took 4 to lynch. Night Five begins now and ends at 12 am forum time May 4th.

THREAD LOCKED

[A Drowned Kernel]

Day Six Start

No one died in the night.

Vote Count 6.0

Not Voting (6): MiX, Dylan32, WestCoastDidds, ashersky, DatSwan, scolapasta

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch. Day Six begins now and ends at 12 am forum time May 11th.

THREAD UNLOCKED

[scolapasta]

Huh. Again.

I can't wait to wake up in the morning and hear all the new theories.

[Dylan32]

Ok. I can only think of two reasons for this. A) Scum has phoned it in (either on purpose or by not checking their QT). B) Scum actually thinks their best play is to let the status quo continue, which would mean Ash and MiX are town (since the status quo for them is getting lynched the next two nights) and they think they can win the 4 person showdown against me and the other 2 members of the assumed!town block.  If B, creatively and well played and good luck.

I personally think the UB should claim now. I understand waiting until 5 people, but there have been a few not!UB claims already, so the pool isn't exactly big for who it might actually be.

Lol. I was about to ask if it was possible for someone to play a game of mafia and not actually look at the QT to avoid knowing they weren't town so they could for all intents and purposes play exactly like town, but by having to check in in the personal QT before game start I don't think so (if that was something we had to do this game).

[ashersky]

I'm convinced MiX is the only player with the gumption to do this.  My read there hasn't changed, of course.

If Dylan is lying, not killing Dylan makes senses as a way of not giving away the lie (because scum would kill the truthful claimed role to keep him from being IC-ish during the day).  Except no counterclaims makes that unlikely.  Except the possible super doctor theory, which seems outlandish at this point (as opposed to the first time, where it seemed more possible).

Can someone good at stats do the math?  Chances that a doctor successfully blocked Dylan's shot three nights in a row?  Seems pretty slim.

So then, crazy scum ploy, or given up scum, per Dylan's thinking, which seems to track.

The state of play is still heavily in town's favor.  I think the bloc idea is the unsafest move, though, because if the bloc is wrong, we lose.

Six alive...ML = 5 alive.  NoK means 5 alive, 3 to lynch while NK means 4 alive, 3 to lynch.  In the first situation, lynch as normal, in the second, NL to see if they shoot again and give us 3-man LYLO.

Either way, we are guaranteed 3 days (including today) to get this right.

Or we could have won days ago by listening to me from the beginning.

[MiX]

Swan, listen to me for once, will ya?

Vote: ash, he's the only player alive that is capable of doing this.

Also I'm looking at the PPE and he mentioned a doctor again which is negative percent of existing which means he's just pulling stuff out of his ass, he's not trying to help town.

Also also, to other town: stop pushing mislynches, thank you and lynch ash I've had enough of him being scum.

If you don't believe me, then you should've lynched me yesterday instead of towny mctown yuma.

PPE I'm not reading any posts today we autolynch ash. Oh, lol no one died again.

[MiX]

Or we could have won days ago by listening to me from the beginning.

Yes.

Also the ICs are terrible, sorry for saying that but I've had enough of Swan.

I submitted a kill for Swan yesterday. So I can't be super hidden scum.

Just lynch ash please I'm not even trying to push any mislynches I just knew yuma was a terrible lynch except no one fucking cares about what the 1v1 says.

LYNCH IN THE SCUMREADS AND NOT THE TOWNREADS TOWN.

Thank you and I'm tired of this game.

[ashersky]

vote: MiX

You make it too easy.  I didn't even open with a vote because I hoped the somewhat level, MiX would be coming back.

Neutral parties, just read the last two posts by MiX...

He regurgitates my statement that he's the only player capable of this.
He continues to want to control the information that is provided to all, to specifically hide actual possibilities (no matter how far-fetched).  Remember that the only two players who know 100% whether or not Dylan is lying are Dylan and the remaining scum.  The rest of us can only trust/believe/etc.
He complains about mislynches while actively taking part in mislynches all game.  He also helped to make sure the one player who knows me better than any other was removed from the game without using an NK.
He is exasperated.

MiX is scum, my hat offer is still on the table.

[ashersky]

Look, I'll make it easy for all the other town members of this game.

Trust me, lynch MiX.  We win.  If I'm wrong, I promise I wwill do the following:

--vote myself in my first post tomorrow (assuming I'm alive)
--eat a hat
--never play another game of forum mafia ever again

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

Is this an ATE?  Absolutely.  Is it because I'm so incredibly frustrated that I am unable to convince anyone of anything anymore, when at one point in the history of f.ds mafia I was one of the absolute best players on the site?  Yes.  Am I conceited and terrible for saying something like that?  I don't think so -- I think many players who were here during those times would say I am making a fair statement.

I feel like one of those very elite athletes who doesn't retired before they aren't the best anymore; or come back from retirement to play even though they aren't as good as they used to be.  It's a terrible feeling, really, and I am pretty sure I made a huge mistake coming back to play mafia at all.  But man it is fun.

I'm sorry.

[ashersky]

I guess I'm just done.  I can request a sub, although at this late juncture, it seems difficult to do.

[MiX]

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

I'll just say what I need to say.

You are wrong. So now imagine you are lynched. What will you do.

I guess I'm just done.  I can request a sub, although at this late juncture, it seems difficult to do.

Just lynch us both and stop listening to Swan, this is a message to everyone else in this game.

[MiX]

Ok, ash. What is there that makes me 100% scum. Cause I can fight logic forever but if you just assume your previous arguments were correct then idk.

I don't think you have the strength to do this, and I probably don't have the strength to defend either, so you can just accept the fact that if you are...no. This game's fate's sealed regardless of anything, the yuma mislynch means we must lynch me and ash one after the other and scum either wins or loses the game's decided.

GG. The game's over at this point.

[ashersky]

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

I'll just say what I need to say.

You are wrong. So now imagine you are lynched. What will you do.

I don't need to imagine.  I already wrote what I would do.  Selfvote, eat a hat, quit mafia.

[MiX]

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

I'll just say what I need to say.

You are wrong. So now imagine you are lynched. What will you do.

I don't need to imagine.  I already wrote what I would do.  Selfvote, eat a hat, quit mafia.

No I mean if you are lynched. You said you would leave since I was scum. I am not. So what will you do?

[ashersky]

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

I'll just say what I need to say.

You are wrong. So now imagine you are lynched. What will you do.

I don't need to imagine.  I already wrote what I would do.  Selfvote, eat a hat, quit mafia.

No I mean if you are lynched. You said you would leave since I was scum. I am not. So what will you do?

I also said what I would do if I was lynched, just quit mafia.  No hat to eat and no way to self vote.

If you mean if I am wrong and then I am lynched.  Well then we lose.

[MiX]

If you lynch me, only the third option is on the table.  Because there's nothing more frustrating than being right for so long, having no one believe you, and then losing to that player.

I'll just say what I need to say.

You are wrong. So now imagine you are lynched. What will you do.

I don't need to imagine.  I already wrote what I would do.  Selfvote, eat a hat, quit mafia.

No I mean if you are lynched. You said you would leave since I was scum. I am not. So what will you do?

I also said what I would do if I was lynched, just quit mafia.  No hat to eat and no way to self vote.

If you mean if I am wrong and then I am lynched.  Well then we lose.

Yes, yes we do lose. Will you do anything else?

[ashersky]

What else would I do?

Do you mean apologize?  If you want.