Catching up now. This day started fast!
We have six others on wagon. How many scum rode the known (to them) mislynch of a PR? 2? Hilariously, if the traitor isn't recruited, they don't know if they are on wagon together or not.
This may not be right. Because Morgrim is Morgrim, scum might not know if he was their traitor who got away with a fakeclaim. So scum might not know if they are lynching a town PR or not.
I also don't like the idea of marketing the lynch pool so soon. Let's see what our IC had to say before we do anything like that
I'm also really interested to hear what the IC has to say before getting too deep into an analytic spiral.
No. To both of you. You scumhunt on your own.
Re: ash. I do not like his play today. At all. But I do not see a clear through-line for scum!ash to be doing what he's doing. I believe this is more likely tunneling-his-reads town!ash, at least right now. Like this:
And every other player who hasn't posted yet? Why single out manda, exactly at the moment she was about to Post? That is very, very odd.
That is just hardcore tunneling on Jimmmmm. Of course manda stands out more than other lurkers. This is a reasonable action by Jimmmmm.
But - and this is where I say screw it, I'm making assumptions! -
vote: Jimmmmm. At the end of D1, I had the same thoughts as Robz here:
Ash, I had similar thoughts about Jimm, but I think they are best explored Day 2. Well, we need the flip for one thing. For another, I don't want to clue scum in to who they should shoot based on where my suspicions currently lie.
which was referring to ash here:
This:
I want to lynch Morgrim because he's frustrating and unhelpful. But I'm loath to lynch a claimed PR who, if truthful, can potentially give us decent results.
Plus this:
Well there you go. I guess lynching claimed PRs is kind of what we do here.
= noticable hesitation while still wanting to see willing to go with the lynch. Scum afraid of lynching the Traitor? Scum not wanting to look like he's taking the easy lynch option? Town truly hesitant?
I do NOT like the fact that I am thinking like ashersky, but if he's town that's fine, and I'm now thinking much more in that direction. And this is what I was talking about with my "everyone shut up and wait for a flip" after Jimmmmm's cred-move and e's insanity.
Basically - if there's scum off-wagon, it's probably Jimmmmm.
Wha happened today? Not much, mostly ashersky being ashersky. Seems strange to me to look for scum off-wagon, one would think that scum is quite happy to lynch a claimed PR.
Yes, but - and even this requires an assumption - if they know Morgrim is a PR, they know how obvious it would look to be on-wagon. At least one scum is on wagon for sure, there is no doubt about that. Maybe 2 or 3. But it's WIFOM.
I have no idea what to make of the e situation right now. It would be so easy for scum to try to frame e if he is town.