Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Galzria]

Epic.

Wonderfully done Chairs. Perfect choices each and every night (yes, N1 too. Gave you and everybody else a ton of information with very little lost in terms of town power, since Ash was a VT at that point).

Very well done town.

[Galzria]

I'll note that, with the exception of mail-mi (go figure) every person listed their scummiest reads to be either Chairs (who wasn't going to Vig himself), or Mail-Mi.

Mail-Mi didn't stand much of a chance.

[Archetype]

I was vaguely following, but awesome job chairs! You shouldbe a Vig more often!

Good job to Galzria, too!

[Galzria]

Woo hoo!

Awesome vigging.  Town player in a single game of the year mafia award.

Yep, this.

[ashersky]

I'll discuss my thoughts on this when I can tether my phone and type, but I'm happy I was right.

What was your thought process on why to kill me N1?

I agree with most everyone that I wasn't a bad target.  Scum would have been a better target, obviously, but Galz is right that my flip was super-helpful for town in that it solidified a lot of town reads on me, let you know I wasn't trying to mislead anyone, and I had used my power (to protect the MVP Vig, for which I deserve props, I've decided).

[yuma]

Woo hoo!

Awesome vigging.  Town player in a single game of the year mafia award.

Yep, this.

agreed! This was a very fun game. Oh and chairs... again, I initially was very against your shot on ashersky--because I knew that ashersky was a doctor--but once galz explained to me why it was a good move I decided to continue with something of a dumb gambit to get in an argument with the IC. Nearly everything I said after the first post was pretty much made up. From my vantage point killing ash was bad, but from yours. It was a pretty good choice, well done on everyone else.

I would love to hear the logic behind your kills. Did you explain them in PM form to mcmc and voltgloss?

[yuma]

This means that, starting tomorrow, Game of Thrones will be the only mafia game running!

I'll get stack the deck open for signups in the next day. But won't be starting it until ToyStory is well under way.

[EFHW]

Congratulations to chairs!  And Town.

[EFHW]

play hangman!

[yuma]

Can we be given the mod and mafia QT?

[yuma]

WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? Chairs was vig? But...But.... he said he wouldn't vig night 1! Argh! I was so sure it was Volt or Nkirbit. UGH.

Ah well. I need to stop being scum in this set up 

I actually think this was one of your stronger performances as you, as well as your teammates, kinda got caught in some unfortunate circumstances. I really liked your bussing of TA day1 and staying away from the sudgy wagon. I know voltaire pointed attention to it (saying it was similar to what I was calling out theorel for), but I felt it was really well done and very authentic. There certainly weren't any of the "alarm bells," and I think I would have been hesitant to lynch you had I been alive and chairs not shot you day4.

[Galzria]

I'll discuss my thoughts on this when I can tether my phone and type, but I'm happy I was right.

What was your thought process on why to kill me N1?

I agree with most everyone that I wasn't a bad target.  Scum would have been a better target, obviously, but Galz is right that my flip was super-helpful for town in that it solidified a lot of town reads on me, let you know I wasn't trying to mislead anyone, and I had used my power (to protect the MVP Vig, for which I deserve props, I've decided).

Hey, I'll give you props for that, even if he wasn't shot.

And I really hope you don't hate me as an IC. I know that both this game and HP were rough on you.

[nkirbit]

WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? Chairs was vig? But...But.... he said he wouldn't vig night 1! Argh! I was so sure it was Volt or Nkirbit. UGH.

Ah well. I need to stop being scum in this set up 

I actually think this was one of your stronger performances as you, as well as your teammates, kinda got caught in some unfortunate circumstances. I really liked your bussing of TA day1 and staying away from the sudgy wagon. I know voltaire pointed attention to it (saying it was similar to what I was calling out theorel for), but I felt it was really well done and very authentic. There certainly weren't any of the "alarm bells," and I think I would have been hesitant to lynch you had I been alive and chairs not shot you day4.

I agree with this, I (and others, I think) might have gotten to Mail-Mi by process of elimination, but that was really it.. you didn't do anything that made me think you were scum at all.

[sudgy]

Great job town.  Killing four scum in three days?  I've never heard of that happening before!

Also, as I said in the speccy, I think I would have still acted similar to how I did if I was town.  What I posted was all entirely genuine, including how to catch me (other than that I was town, obviously).

[chairs]

Okay, so here's the process I had (yuma, I'm afraid I didn't PM the mods anything at the time to explain my shots):

D1: I said I wasn't going to shoot anybody.  HOWEVER, we didn't all agree to that, and (this is key) we D1 lynched the SK.  This, in particular, really changed my mind (but I'm glad I claimed not-going-to-shoot because it threw me off the vig-hunting that could have happened).

N1: I wasn't sure who the Mafia were, not having a ton of reads on anybody, and I -really- felt like the best thing I could do was be 100% sure that ashersky was really a 1-shot doctor (no offense, ash, but if anybody was going to fakeclaim 1-shot doc it would be you!) and in the process give the rest of Town a better idea of setup - something that would end up key to Town D3 play, as the N1 and N2 shots confirmed we had a full vigilante without any need to claim.

D2: Theorel almost immediately jumped out for EVERYBODY, and got lynched.  In the process, TA sounded somewhat insincere and tripped a little bell in my head.  I was actually most worried by that shot - was I unintentionally shooting the doctor who was hoping to be obv-mislynch enough that Mafia wouldn't shoot him? I actually didn't recognize yuma as doctor and was surprised at the flip later.

N2: As stated, TA felt scummy to me after D2, so I felt it was worthwhile to risk shooting the doc - and luckily I was right and he wasn't just intentionally playing scummy.  This really got me excited, honestly, more than the D3 shot even, because it was my weakest shot.

D3: The no-lynch plan was awesome, and the quick "scum to chum" that everybody wrote up sealed the deal.  I knew for sure after reading those that it was either mail-mi or nkirbit (or I was -really- being well-played by Voltaire or Xerxes), and after reading just the scum to chum a few times, I decided mail-mi would be N3's shot and nkirbit would be N4.

N3: As stated, going into N3 I'd already picked N3/N4 vig targets.  I think if we'd gone to D4 we'd quickhammer a no-lynch.

[chairs]

Also, I don't see the links for mod/mafia/speccy QT, please advise.

[nkirbit]

Yeah, Galz, what gave away Yuma being the doctor?  I didn't notice anything day1.

[Galzria]

Yeah, Galz, what gave away Yuma being the doctor?  I didn't notice anything day1.

He didn't policy lynch Ash for self voting.

[Galzria]

Yeah, Galz, what gave away Yuma being the doctor?  I didn't notice anything day1.

He didn't policy lynch Ash for self voting.

And I'm dead serious here. This tipped me into reading his every defense of Ashersky. The way he spoke about finding out the truth later in the game, combined with how he pushed me to get off Ashersky, after noting the lack of a policy vote, left me certain he was the Doctor. Had we gotten to mylo/lylo, or whenever I decided claiming was going to happen, if he claimed anything else I would've lynched him on the spot.

[ashersky]

I'll discuss my thoughts on this when I can tether my phone and type, but I'm happy I was right.

What was your thought process on why to kill me N1?

I agree with most everyone that I wasn't a bad target.  Scum would have been a better target, obviously, but Galz is right that my flip was super-helpful for town in that it solidified a lot of town reads on me, let you know I wasn't trying to mislead anyone, and I had used my power (to protect the MVP Vig, for which I deserve props, I've decided).

Hey, I'll give you props for that, even if he wasn't shot.

And I really hope you don't hate me as an IC. I know that both this game and HP were rough on you.

We may have a love/hate relationship when we are both town, but we can't argue with results.  I played a bigger part in HP, but in both games, I think the arguments we had were incidental to the progress we made together.

You get me better than anyone, except maybe yuma.  Riling me up is part of getting more out of me as town (and probably, catching me as scum at some point).  The formula works.

[mail-mi]

WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? Chairs was vig? But...But.... he said he wouldn't vig night 1! Argh! I was so sure it was Volt or Nkirbit. UGH.

Ah well. I need to stop being scum in this set up 

I actually think this was one of your stronger performances as you, as well as your teammates, kinda got caught in some unfortunate circumstances. I really liked your bussing of TA day1 and staying away from the sudgy wagon. I know voltaire pointed attention to it (saying it was similar to what I was calling out theorel for), but I felt it was really well done and very authentic. There certainly weren't any of the "alarm bells," and I think I would have been hesitant to lynch you had I been alive and chairs not shot you day4.

[insert hooray cat]

Hey hey hey.... 2 spots open in toy story!

[mcmcsalot]

Sorry been busy,

Here's the qt's

Speccy http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/bFUdA2GzWEbJ

Mod http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/c2vdpGZTfuJyq

Mafia http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/B7xt8ckXuCU

[ashersky]

So I doctored scum TA it seems.  So I give back any props for that.

[Galzria]

I love that I was never protected, yet never died.

[Eevee]

Winning is fun!