I'm always interested to know what are the most appreciated cards, and know after your first plays with guilds, which are your favourites ?
For my part, the first is Butcher, I think it's a very skill card with many options, one of the best remodel variant really. After that, Stonemason but more for the on-play effect than for the overpay. It is a little bit like develop : not so useful and tricky, but when you can do something good with it you feel great. I like the overpay effect too of course, because it makes the card much stronger.
Overall I like all the cards in the set, but Doctor and Soothsayer slightly less than the rest. I haven't payed so much with the guilds cards of course, so my opinion can change with the time.