Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jimmmmm]

Resistance: Avalon

Roles:

Good
Merlin: knows who the Evil players are
Percival: knows who Merlin is

Evil
Assassin: if Evil loses, names a player, and if that player is Merlin, Evil wins
Mordred: unknown to Merlin
Oberon: unknown to the other Evil players
Morgana: appears to Percival alongside Merlin

Wikipedia page

Players:
1. Tables
2. liopoil
3. Archetype
4. shraeye
5. Dsell
6. Twistedarcher
7. nkirbit
8. mail-mi
9. Qvist ashersky


Mission 1: 3 people - liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit - SUCCESS!
Mission 2: 4 people - liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi - FAILURE!
Mission 3: 4 people - liopoil, Archetype, nkirbit, ashersky - FAILURE!
Mission 4: 5 people - Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit, ashersky - SUCCESS!
Mission 5: 5 people - Archetype, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, ashersky - FAILURE!


Mission 1, Proposal 1
Leader: nkirbit
Proposed Team: liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: liopoil, Twistedarcher
Reject: Tables, Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit, mail-mi, Qvist ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 1, Proposal 2
Leader: mail-mi
Proposed Team: Dsell, Twistedarcher, mail-mi
Votes
Accept: Dsell, Twistedarcher, mail-mi
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, nkirbit, Qvist ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 1, Proposal 3
Leader: Qvist ashersky
Proposed Team: shraeye, Twistedarcher, Qvist ashersky
Votes
Accept: shraeye, Twistedarcher, mail-mi, ashersky
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, Dsell, nkirbit
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 1, Proposal 4
Leader: Tables
Proposed Team: Tables, Dsell, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Tables, shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit
Reject: liopoil, Archetype, Twistedarcher, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 1, Proposal 5
Leader: liopoil
Proposed Team: liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Proposal is accepted.

Results
Succeed: 3
Fail: 0
The Mission is a Success!



Mission 2, Proposal 1
Leader: Archetype
Proposed Team: liopoil, Archetype, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: liopoil, Archetype, Dsell
Reject: Tables, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 2, Proposal 2
Leader: shraeye
Proposed Team: liopoil, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Dsell, Twistedarcher
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, nkirbit, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 2, Proposal 3
Leader: Dsell
Proposed Team: shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Dsell
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 2, Proposal 4
Leader: Twistedarcher
Proposed Team: liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi
Votes
Accept: liopoil, shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, mail-mi
Reject: Tables, Archetype, nkirbit, ashersky
Proposal is accepted.

Results
Succeed: 3
Fail: 1
The Mission is a Failure!



Mission 3, Proposal 1
Leader: nkirbit
Proposed Team: Archetype, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Archetype, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Dsell, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 3, Proposal 2
Leader: mail-mi
Proposed Team: shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit, mail-mi
Votes
Accept: mail-mi
Reject: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 3, Proposal 3
Leader: ashersky
Proposed Team: liopoil, shraeye, nkirbit, ashersky
Votes
Accept: liopoil, ashersky
Reject: Tables, Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 3, Proposal 4
Leader: Tables
Proposed Team: Tables, liopoil, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Tables, shraeye, Twistedarcher 
Reject: liopoil, Archetype, Dsell, nkirbit, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 3, Proposal 5
Leader: liopoil
Proposed Team: liopoil, Archetype, nkirbit, ashersky
Proposal is accepted.

Results
Succeed: 3
Fail: 1
The Mission is a Failure!



Mission 4, Proposal 1
Leader: Archetype
Proposed Team: Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit, ashersky
Votes
Accept: Tables, liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, nkirbit, ashersky
Reject: Twistedarcher, mail-mi
Proposal is accepted.

Results
Succeed: 5
Fail: 0
The Mission is a Success!



Mission 5, Proposal 1
Leader: shraeye
Proposed Team: Tables, Archetype, shraeye, nkirbit, ashersky
Votes
Accept: Tables, shraeye, ashersky 
Reject: liopoil, Archetype, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 5, Proposal 2
Leader: Dsell
Proposed Team: Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, nkirbit
Votes
Accept: Archetype, Dsell 
Reject: Tables, liopoil, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, mail-mi, ashersky
Proposal is rejected.


Mission 5, Proposal 3
Leader: Twistedarcher
Proposed Team: Archetype, shraeye, Twistedarcher, nkirbit, ashersky
Votes
Accept: liopoil, Archetype, shraeye, Dsell, Twistedarcher, ashersky 
Reject: Tables, nkirbit, mail-mi
Proposal is accepted.

Results
Succeed: 4
Fail: 1
The Mission is a Failure!

The Evil Team wins!

[Tables]

/in

7 players is generally the sweet spot for Resistance, so I'd like those.

I've found that Mordred + Percival + LotL is resistance sided, but Mordred + Percival seems okay, or Morgana + LotL. I'll probably go with any setup.

[liopoil]

hmmm, interesting. /in.

[shraeye]

Why is 'unknown' written like that?

[Archetype]

Why is 'unknown' written like that?

I guess it'll have to stay unkn[/i]own.

/in

[Jimmmmm]

Why is 'unknown' written like that?

http://boardgamegeek.com/thread/864435/riddled-with-typos-a-first-impression-revised

[shraeye]

Now I understand.  And now I hope to be an 'Unkown' character.

[Jimmmmm]

Now I understand.  And now I hope to be an 'Unkown' character.

I'm taking that as an /in and requesting at least one of Mordred and Oberon.

[shraeye]

I formally request both!  at the same time!

[Jimmmmm]

I formally request both!  at the same time!

If we get at least 7 players and no formal requests to the contrary, consider it done.

[Dsell]

I think I will /in this.

[Twistedarcher]

/in

[liopoil]

oh we're requesting? and we can request two things at once? I'd like to be the assassin and percival at the same time, thanks.

[Jimmmmm]

oh we're requesting? and we can request two things at once? I'd like to be the assassin and percival at the same time, thanks.

I'm taking requests for what roles should or shouldn't be in the game, and I interpreted shraeye's request as such. Roles will of course be distributed entirely randomly.

[Jimmmmm]

Also, I'd like to know if the people would prefer I restrict the number of players to something smaller than 10, or are happy for me to keep taking sign-ups if we pass 7 or 8.

[Dsell]

I think 7 or 8 is nice, and a bit less to read...

[liopoil]

I assumed they would, I mean, if they weren't, that wouldn't work at all. I don't know any other roles, these look fine though.

for number of people, probably no more than 9.

[shraeye]

oh we're requesting? and we can request two things at once? I'd like to be the assassin and percival at the same time, thanks.

I'm taking requests for what roles should or shouldn't be in the game, and I interpreted shraeye's request as such. Roles will of course be distributed entirely randomly.

Oh, well I don't care what's in the game, as long as I get ALL of the cool roles.

[liopoil]

...says the guy who's running VANILLA resistance right now...

[Jimmmmm]

...says the guy who's running VANILLA resistance right now...

+1

[Jimmmmm]

Full disclosure, if we get at least 7 players and there aren't any strong objections, I'll probably put all of the listed roles in and if necessary combine the Assassin with one of the other Evil roles.

[shraeye]

...says the guy who's running VANILLA resistance right now...

Right.  The only cool role in Vanilla Resistance is mod.  And I have it.

[nkirbit]

/in.  All the roles possible!

[nkirbit]

But not plot cards.  TA had been telling me for months that I need to play with plot cards, and I finally did in a few games I played with him, and they ruined every single game

[Dsell]

I prefer no plot cards too, at least for this game.