It seems that Paper is too much for Rock to deal with
To make it short I used Rock twice, first time I robbed his Paper and the second time, I melded paper with my 1st action and activated Rock to finish the job, well done.
Don't bother about the other parts it is just another usual game between us...and yes this Hideo guy is one of my apprentice, I taught him how to play innovation long ago and he is a beast now beating nearly everybody in F14 plaform, the kind of early game momentum by him is just overwhelming and choke you up soon with achievements by achievements