Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[AdamH]

Originally in the Survivor rules they were told not to talk about the game. Back when juries respected that I feel that the game was better. It's impossible to enforce now so bitter people have poisoned juries before and created voting blocs that made me unhappy.

It's just my opinion. Perhaps an effort can be made to try and prevent jurors from talking about the game. At least to not encourage them to do it by having a QT that wouldn't be good for anything else.

[mcmcsalot]

I agree with not being able to talk about the game. I think it would be
More fun as a jury member to get first reactions to others final tribal question/responses when they are done and be just as shocked as the players when they find out who wins.

I disagree with 2 players, I think three created infinitely more alliance choices and alot less potential for the bring the one you can beat strategy, surrounding yourself with two complete losers is tough and you look bad, you gotta figure out how to bring one obvious loser and one good candidate who you can out talk/had less allies.

[Archetype]

I don't think you should have an in-game mechanic for allowing undetected conversations. I think you should do just the opposite and have a mechanic for detecting conversations.

So you can talk as much as you want with in private with people, but there is a slight chance of your message being overheard by another player. This is in place of talking as much as you want and having it always be detected, but there is a slight chance that your messaging will be private.

[mcmcsalot]

Added note from what I said in the other thread. I thin the game could really evolve if we took a bit of role playing into it, this also helps because a conversation between two people could just be about their favorite foods or anything else. But peoe would need
To be into the whole let talk because we need to get some
Water and actually just talk.

[AdamH]

F2 vs F3 has long been an area of disagreement.

Regardless of what actually happens, I'm quite certain that the mods shouldn't tell us which is happening until right before the final immunity challenge, though.