Okay, first chance I've had to read up.
I have to say, I also felt very sure of my Robz vote, even if some don't agree with my rationale. I laid out the case as I saw it, and stuck with it. I did change for the self-vote at one point, which I still see as anti-town, but in the end I felt like I made the right decision. Of course, I woke up the next day and saw the results, which were unfortunate.
On D2 reads, after the NK of Volt, I think looking at his interactions is important. I think he was suspicious of Grujah and Cuzz early, and added Eevee (and me) after being chickened. He was clearly convinced on Robz, from what I could understand of his chicken speak, for the lynch.
I think we should note the "lurkers" from D1, especially Shraeye. I know he had his Monday fun day thing, but before that there was little communication from him. I will say his D2 stuff has been better, so that's a change for the better...or for his rep.
I don't get the Eevee wagon--I haven't gotten a scummy feel from him recently (even with his "I promised to go for Ash" thing and sheeping yuma before yuma even did his analysis -- town Eevee is usually "votes to quickly" Eevee). As has been noted, I had the "odd" hedgy comment which no one liked, about him, but otherwise, Eevee's read town to me. I don't think that's a good lynch.
On D1, I mentioned Grujah and Galz were my biggest town reads. It seems unlikely that both are town though, in retrospect, given our loss of Volt and Robz. Both of them had suspicions of them on D1 at different stages. They were both on the Robz wagon (although I don't think we can use position on the wagon for too much analysis, given the hectic deadline).
D2 reads seem to vary on the two from others, but I lean toward Grujah being town, based on his take on Insom's actions and his various reads so far.
I like Archetype's review of C_F (even if it seems a bit OMGUS-fueled) who I also rank on the scummy side. He was the antithesis of lurker on D1, but didn't offer much, and instead wagon hunted and had others do his work for him. But more than that, his throwaway response to Arch was not helpful at all, and doesn't paint him in a town light.
So, in summary, scum reads are (not in order): C_F, Galzria, Shraeye
town reads: Grujah, Eevee, Arch