Actually, Mic played Fabian, who went 1-3 before dropping, so on Challonge he'd be 4 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 4, which is 8 for tiebreaker, or 12 total. But for you, since shark_bait was only 1-3, you have 1 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 4 on Challonge, 7 for tiebreaker, 12 altogether.
That doesn't take into account unplayed matches and dropouts; as described in the tiebreaking thread, we can't fault people for having played someone who later dropped. The correct numbers from my spreadsheet are:
Mic Qsenoch: 4 (HME); 1.5 (ddubois, early drop); 1.5 (Fabian, early drop); 3 (lespuetere); 4 (Stef) = 8.5 (top and bottom dropped) then 14 (no drops)
Rabid: 1.5 (Eevee, early drop); 1.5 (shark bait, early drop); 2 (Obi Wan Bonogi); 3 (cayvie); 4 (HME) = 6.5 (top and bottom dropped) then 12 (no drops)