Finally, after I thought it wouldn't be too interesting to compile a list with only 9 people participating, but after a few of you asked about it, here it is now:
The list of your favourite cards you can find here:https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjovnuYeeSkidHl2YnhHVVB5SWVOS0oxQWtCSUZVWFE
Like I said, it is still not very significant. One voter can still scramble the list.
But the Top 10 kingdom basically would be:
Fishing Village, Bishop, Menagerie, Wharf, Governor, Hamlet, Grand Market, Venture, Salvager, Laboratory
I'm a little surprised by Venture here, but beside of that, there is no really surprise IMHO.
I think it's also very intereting that so "basic" cards like Laboratory (10.) and Festival (12.) ranked so good.
The bottom 10 kingdom would be:
Duchess, Thief, Secret Chamber, Stash, Chancellor, Philosopher's Stone, Moat, Transmute, Counting House, Treasure Map
I think there are no big surprises, that these cards ranked very low, but I even expected some other cards like Saboteur in the bottom 10.
So, now go ahead and play those kingdoms with your friends or read some more statistics:
The 3 VP chip generating cards ranked all very good (Bishop 2., Goons 17., Monument 20.).
Duration cards also ranked very good, only one card is in the bottom half
(Fishing Village 1., Wharf 4., Tactician 27., Caravan 37., Haven 49., Lighthouse 68., Merchant Ship 69., Outpost 106.)
Terminal draw cards for Big Money ranked very low beside of Wharf.
Alternative VP cards were distributed from top to bottom with Tunnel being the favourite and I'm a little bit surprised by some low rankings.
(Tunnel 33., Vineyard 43., Fairgrounds 52., Island 58., Harem 62., Nobles 67., Farmland 83., Gardens 88., Silk Road 108., Duke 114., Great Hall 117.)
Reaction cards ranked all very low beside of Tunnel and Horse Traders
(Tunnel 33., Horse Traders 48., Watchtower 78., Fool's Gold 89., Trader 112., Moat 151., Secret Chamber 155.)
The favourite attacks were Goons 20., Jester 39., Minion 56. and Young Witch 70. as the best curser. So attacks were basically ranked very low.
The least favourite attacks were Thief 156., Saboteur 144., Bureaucrat 143. and Oracle 140.
Sea Hag (135.) was the least favourite curser. For me it was surprising to see it above Familiar (118.) as everybody complains about its swingyness.
Most Treasure cards ranked really low (Stash 154., Philosopher's Stone 152., Cache 139., Talisman 134., ...),
but there were a few which also ranked pretty high (Venture 8., Hoard 15., Horn of Plenty 26.)
The bottom cards also had the highest consensus with Transmute being a big outlier.
Other cards with high consensus were Nomad Camp, Woodcutter, Market, Rabble, Haven, Scout and of course Fishing Village.
On the other side there are the 10 cards which divide the community in two parts:
Farmland, Contraband, Fool's Gold, Ill-Gotten Gains, Harvest, Alchemist, Mountebank, Watchtower, Torturer and Ambassador as the
most controversial card.
The favourite Potion cost cards were Apothecary (32.), Vineyard (43.) and University (71.) and the least favourite being Possession (137.), Transmute (150.), Philosopher's Stone (152.).
That leads to the compiled list of the favourite expansions:
1. Cornucopia 47.31
2. Prosperity 61.36
3. Seaside 82.58
4. Hinterlands 83.50
5. Intrigue 84.88
6. Alchemy 89.75
7. Base 90.40
(8. Promo 95.40)
=> a big lead for Cornucopia and Prosperity
Thanks for all the contribution, even though there were only 9 entries. I compiled a list for myself and I know that sorting 157 is very difficult and time consuming.
I'm planning for an update for both of my lists. And I have an idea for especially this list to get more entries and still being significant. You'll see...