Part 3 of 6: Jotheonah:
Day 1 Posts:
#41, #42, #43, #47, #52, #53, #55, #57, #59, #64, #67, #68, #129, #130, #149, #150, #152, #153, #156, #159, #167, #181, #182, #185, #186, #189, #191, #201, #220, #223, #228, #230, #236
Posts of interest:
#52 - Votes no lynch
#53 - Slight suspicion of Robz
#57 - Defends no lynch vote
#64 - Slightly suspicious of Kuildeous and Bozzball, more suspicious of Robz
#67 - Backs down from NL vote, suspects Tables, trusts Volt
#129 - Officially unvotes NL, still suspects Tables
#130 - Suspects Morgrim, but would lynch Kuildeous for being inactive with no stated reason
#149 - Strongly suspects Morgrim. Thinks M/G could be a pair. Ready to cast vote (doesn't), still suspects Kuildeous and Tables
#152 - Drops suspicion of Galzria, slightly suspicious of Bozzball
#156 - Sees Tables as possible Mafia #2
#167 - Officially votes Morgrim, suspicious of Kuildeous
#220 - Attempts to unvote
Relevant Conclusions: Wow, I didn't realize how scattered J was day 1! He suspected close to everybody. Hard to read. Set up a good defense for future days if he is Mafia, because he can claim he suspected everyone at some point, so can't be partners with anyone. Could also just be excitable town play. Few of his suspicions really carried much weight, and most were because of the arguments of others. Tough call.
Day 2 Posts:
#250, #251, #252, #257, #258, #262, #263, #269, #285, #294, #298, #299, #312, #313, #316, #322, #327, #332, #337, #355, #377, #379, #398, #399, #401, #402, #403, #414, #416, #421, 424, #428, #434, #435, #438, #439, #443, #448, #457, #473, #478, #481, #482, #485, #489, #492, #501, #503, #507, #509, #510, #541
Posts of interest:
#250 - Suspects Robz/Voltgloss pair. Presumptively defends Morgrim vote.
#257 - Reaffirms strong suspicion of R/V. Defends unvote after Morgrim lynch. Declares Galzria likely town.
#262 - Teeters about Volt, more sure of Robz
#263 - Reaffirms faith in G. Is bothered by G not trusting him. Supports the rest of G's analysis. Undecided which is Mafia, Robz or Volt, leaning Volt
#269 - Defends late Morgrim unvote
#285 - Tit-for-Tat with Volt. Agrees with Galz "1 in, 1 out" theory. Believes V is probably town.
#294 - Redirects K back to Robz when he suspects J/I more than R/G
#298 - Back and forth with Robz
#316 - Responds to G's inquiry about K: K is #1 suspect outside Robz/Volt, would vote K if group were leaning that way
#355 - Not sure if K/R or K/V most likely. Would vote K now. Doesn't think Insomniac has been helpful
#377 - "Bottom line, if you're sure someone's Mafia, kill them today. Don't wait."
#399 - Agrees with G's analysis of Tables death. Claims lack of faith there are 2 town roles
#414 - Fully lays out case for K, says he's not bandwagoning, is worried about losing G's trust
#443 - Still thinks Volt may be Mafia #2
#457 - Backs off K, votes bozz to illicit a response
#473 - Back to leaning K, but worried about I/V pair
#478 - Reaffirms #473 thoughts
#485 - Backs off I/V pair because I votes for V
#492 - Asks G's opinion of V, states he's still highly suspicious
#503 - Thinks K-I likely
#507 - Really not liking Insomniacs play
#541 - Votes Kuildeous
Relevant Conclusions: Again a bit scattered, but not as bad as Day 1. Back and forth with Robz and Volt all day. I mentioned apprehension day 2 at how badly he appeared to want my friendship, and upon review, this still raises some flags. It was SO pointed and dogged. I don't know. Could be Mafia trying to get in good (which would explain my living still - he's looking for me to defend him day 3) or it could be a false alarm.
Day 3 Posts:
#554, #555, #588, #590, #600, #601, #606, #613
Posts of interest:
#554 - Orders Mafia pairs: R-V, I-V, I-G, I-R. Doesn't buy role claim
#555 - Drops "friendship" with G. Suspects him for living.
#561 - Thinks Robz is Mafia, Insomniac is town
#588 - Stays on Robz
#600 - Accuses Robz of suspecting people who suspect him
#613 - Stays on Robz,, feels I is exonerated by lack of someone defending him
Relevant Conclusions: Wary. Not sold he's Mafia or Town. If Mafia, I got used BIG time day 2, and set up for day 3/4. But he hasn't really pursued me hard after post #555, so not sure. He's been on Robz since day 2 though. Could be town. Although Volt his comment about lack of second town role day 2. Plug that into your M. Rolecop theory that they knew R was Doctor after night 1. It discredits any future claim (like R did day 3). Mafia move or town read?
Not sure here. Wouldn't make a move until day 4 unless something major changes. Very wary however.
Part 4 tonight hopefully...
Author
Topic: Mafia II: Of Goons and Woodcutters GAME OVER Mafia Wins! (Read 95378 times)