Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[2.71828.....]

fang, what are your thoughts on gkrieg? You may have given them but I am too lazy to go back and look

[2.71828.....]

Ok, I looked a bit

Thanks gkrieg.

vote: Didds
I think that's where I want to be.

I'm happy with my vote staying on joth. But I'm also very willing to switch to pasta. At this point, I would only switch to someone other than those 2 for self-preservation.

Why not Didds?

How did gkrieg's responses change your vote?

[infangthief]

fang, what are your thoughts on gkrieg? You may have given them but I am too lazy to go back and look

Not sure really. I didn't like his refusal to consider that mathdude could be scum. Otherwise I think he's ok.

Ok, I looked a bit

Thanks gkrieg.

vote: Didds
I think that's where I want to be.

I'm happy with my vote staying on joth. But I'm also very willing to switch to pasta. At this point, I would only switch to someone other than those 2 for self-preservation.

Why not Didds?

How did gkrieg's responses change your vote?

One reason I voted for him was to try and get him to answer those questions - in particular I wanted clarification on what he thought of Didds.
There was another reason I voted also, which I would prefer not to share.

Once I got those answers I was happy to go back to my primary scum read at the moment.

[infangthief]

I'd still like to know what scolapasta thought the case on gkrieg was.

[WestCoastDidds]

Ok, cool. I feel like I'm not playing the same game as everyone else!

Why is this?


Unrelated, I'm trying to ISO scola, it's so not fun that he was active in his latest scum game. It makes me not want to read it. So I need to go aaaaall the way back to find a game where scola was this inactive. Does anyone know one off the top of their head?

The first BSG, I think

[WestCoastDidds]

EFHW, you did a Didds reread and don't think she's scum.

What do you think of my observation here (post #668)?

As much as I like the metaphor of the nest, I am not at all fond of the idea that anyone could be pushed out of the nest to splat on the sidewalk!

I could see a Didds/MiX/X team

you doing the good drugs? that makes no sense to me at all.

I want to ask, why? I mean, if you are town then you don't need to say this, you just know that it's wrong. Weird (for you, I think?) to say "that makes no sense". Someone's probably already asked why, I'll read on.

I think I see the angle you are taking - it sounds to you, I think, like she doesn't know her own alignment.  I read it as she can't see how e got to that team from the available information.

Question for Didds. Why did e's suggestion of a Didds/Mix/X team make no sense?

Because I’m not scum! And MiX was the person voting for me on Day 1, which doesn’t make any sense to me. If we were a team, why park his vote on me? I don’t think that is  how MiX rolls with a buddy.

[WestCoastDidds]

Yeh, completely sold on Didds/MiX/X.

Didds had better come up with a good reason why that team makes no sense to her.

In a game with a plurality exile, it makes no sense to me that someone would camp out on a partner, especially on D1. There is too much possibility for starting something you can’t slow down, and it’s way better to camp out an odd vote on someone you’d like to eliminate. MiX was on me most of D1, he wouldn’t do that to a partner. He is not a big busser most of the time at all (as opposed to Scola and math who bus early and often).

So, it made no sense to me that I’d be scum but it made even less sense to me that I’d be scum with MiX.

[2.71828.....]

I would vote for Joth or Scola

I’m okay with math or MiX

I’m not going to vote for EFHW, e, or Galz today

What about gkrieg?

[2.71828.....]

What, just under 2 hours from the deadline?

Really not feeling the joth or math wagons, would switch to Didds or pasta, but why don't more people want to exile gkrieg?

[WestCoastDidds]

I would vote for Joth or Scola

I’m okay with math or MiX

I’m not going to vote for EFHW, e, or Galz today

I’m more ambivalent there. I don’t have a ton of experience with him, and I don’t know that I’ve ever seen scum!gk. So, I’m not sure enough to say

What about gkrieg?

[WestCoastDidds]

I would vote for Joth or Scola

I’m okay with math or MiX

I’m not going to vote for EFHW, e, or Galz today

What about gkrieg?

I’m more ambivalent there. I don’t have a ton of experience with him, and I don’t know that I’ve ever seen scum!gk. So, I’m not sure enough to say.

[WestCoastDidds]

What, just under 2 hours from the deadline?

Really not feeling the joth or math wagons, would switch to Didds or pasta, but why don't more people want to exile gkrieg?

Hmmm…. What is there to like about Joths play? Math?

[2.71828.....]

Regarding joth, here is just one thing:

This is a solid case. I'm honestly loving the Didds cases, but I was nervous because of my scumread on e. But that was a day 1 case, so maybe it's time to let it go and go for something stronger.

Vote: WCD

Especially the flip from calling me scum straight out of the gate, then joining me on Didds.

Scum don't flip-flop like that early D2

As for math, the case feels like leftovers from D1, and I didn't like that case then either. I don't see anything that shouts scum!math to me

[2.71828.....]

Vote: Joth

All the people he was following have invited and now he’s doubling down based on what? That I would cede to his demand to exile e?

Why are you voting joth? Wagon analysis from D1? That's what it feels like reading your posts, just trying to verify your rationale

[mathdude]

What, just under 2 hours from the deadline?

Really not feeling the joth or math wagons, would switch to Didds or pasta, but why don't more people want to exile gkrieg?

I'd switch to pasta

[EFHW]

vote: jotheonah That's X-1.

(By the way, last official vote count shows that there is no active double-voter today.)

pretty sure since we lost faust there was gtd to be no other role for us today? Am I reading that incorrectly?

How would you come to that conclusion from what's in the OP?

[infangthief]

vote: scolapasta

[scolapasta]

scolapasta, what is the case on gkrieg?

e's case on him in post #825. I agree that his voting feels opportunistic. It's not great, but I'm less convinced on joth than I was before.

I should be able to check in a couple times before deadline today.

[infangthief]

Ok, cool. I feel like I'm not playing the same game as everyone else!

Why is this?


Unrelated, I'm trying to ISO scola, it's so not fun that he was active in his latest scum game. It makes me not want to read it. So I need to go aaaaall the way back to find a game where scola was this inactive. Does anyone know one off the top of their head?

The first BSG, I think

Just looked that one up, scolapasta was scum and made about 200 posts in that game, seemed fairly active.

Scolapasta, can you think which game Didds might be referring to?

[WestCoastDidds]

Vote: Joth

All the people he was following have invited and now he’s doubling down based on what? That I would cede to his demand to exile e?

Why are you voting joth? Wagon analysis from D1? That's what it feels like reading your posts, just trying to verify your rationale

It’s mostly his voting pattern today. You had some reasons for voting for me and Galz had some reasons. Joth followed say that he was loving the cases. Then both you and Galz moved away, but was suddenly convinced I am scum, but all of his reasons were based in folks who reevaluated their reasons. MiX called it lazy town, but I’m not sure that’s what town Joth looks like. I know my own town knowledge is bound up in that, but as a “case” against me, it was really hollow.

[WestCoastDidds]

Ok, cool. I feel like I'm not playing the same game as everyone else!

Why is this?

Maybe BSG 2. Or something around that time. I’m sorry, I know that is too vague. But I swear there is a game where absent Scola was scum Scola.

Unrelated, I'm trying to ISO scola, it's so not fun that he was active in his latest scum game. It makes me not want to read it. So I need to go aaaaall the way back to find a game where scola was this inactive. Does anyone know one off the top of their head?

The first BSG, I think

Just looked that one up, scolapasta was scum and made about 200 posts in that game, seemed fairly active.

Scolapasta, can you think which game Didds might be referring to?

[infangthief]

Ok, cool. I feel like I'm not playing the same game as everyone else!

Why is this?
 

Unrelated, I'm trying to ISO scola, it's so not fun that he was active in his latest scum game. It makes me not want to read it. So I need to go aaaaall the way back to find a game where scola was this inactive. Does anyone know one off the top of their head?

The first BSG, I think

Just looked that one up, scolapasta was scum and made about 200 posts in that game, seemed fairly active.

Scolapasta, can you think which game Didds might be referring to?

Maybe BSG 2. Or something around that time. I’m sorry, I know that is too vague. But I swear there is a game where absent Scola was scum Scola.

Looked up that one too. He was scum in both. Bit less active in BSG2, once or twice going a couple of days without posting, but much more active than here.

[infangthief]

vote: Didds

I might switch to scolapasta before deadline, or anyone actually.
But I'm going to hold out on Didds for a bit longer.

[mathdude]

Vote: scola

I'm probably not able to get back online before deadline... class starts in 10 minutes!  (While the students are working, I'll try to poke on quickly, but can't guarantee it).

[scolapasta]

Honestly, I can't think of a game were I've been as inactive as D1 this game. I do know in one of my last scum games I wanted to try to be more inactive (as I thought people would read that as town) and I said that to my scum mates. I think that may have been BSG 2 and interestingly enough, WCD was scum with me that game. Scum points for Didds trying to point you to that one fore sure.

Do we have a vote count?