Okay guys, It's time for Iguana's totally convoluted theory: GPD (Galzria, Pubby, Dylan32). (names arranged for maximum hilarious likeness to GID obvs
)
First of all, this is some pretty hypothetical stuff coming right here.
IF the team is GPD, I'm in trouble tonight. It would mean all my reads are correct, and everyone town reads me. That would make me a huge liability for the scum team. Also, IF the team is GPD, MiX's reads are kind of lousy this game. Just sayin'. Right now MiX is not exactly projecting belief in GPD. Those two things would put me at a real risk of dying tonight. THEREFORE, I need to share some things with y'all now on the chance that I won't be able to do it later because I'll be dead.
So, if we exile Dylan today and he flips scum, PLEASE look at pubby and Galzria. Here's a few reasons why:
So I hadn't paid attention to the shorter deadlines, so realizing it's tomorrow, I'll Vote: Glooble for now. I don't have any strong scumreads yet, but there's actually been more good conversations that will be useful for scumhunting after a flip or two than I remember in recent RMM D1s (thanks to the relative lack of human/cylon/military/civilian/forwards-backwards-timeline oriented conversations lol).
Right now I think iguana is town, and Awaclus and faust are somewhat towny. I would be willing to exile basically any one of {Glooble, WCD, Swowl, e, EFHW}.
ppe 2
Dylan puts a couple towns on his town list, lists a bunch of towns as would exile, and totally ignores Pubby/Galz and a few others. Note that the only other people he ignores are MiX (obvs), Mathdude, and me. So the ommission of Galz and Pubby here is a pretty big chunk of the omitted players.
After reading both e and galz, I just think e is more likely to flip scum than galz. Also, galz, as e admitted, had really good points countering the case.
Vote: e
L-1
-snip-
Dylan comes back after some lurking and wants an e exile a lot more than a Galz exile. Note that several of his next posts argue pretty hard for the e exile... Is that something scum does in a T v T situation? (Again, I don't know for sure that Dylan is scum... this is my hypothetical contribution to D3 in case I die).
Vote Count 1.?.MiX
Galzria (6): faust, WestCoastDidds, EFHW, Awaclus, Glooble, iguanaiguana
2.71828.... (3): Swowl, mathdude, Dylan32
iguanaiguana (1): pubby
Glooble (1): Galzria
No exile (2): 2.71828...., MiX
This wagon is really really important!!!!!! faust, WCD and EFHW are the older votes on Galz. Then, after e's claim... a surge of new votes for Galz comes in. Awaclus is TOWN! Iguanaiguana is TOWN! Glooble is the only unknown here. In sum... I find it highly unlikely that both Galz and Glooble can be town... especially if Dylan flips scum. PLEASE don't forget this!!!
After Galz goes L-1, Dylan comes and says this:
Not necessarily intent right now, but I'm willing to hammer galz if I am not going to convince anyone to come back onto the e wagon.
If Dylan is scum, that's an indication that Galz is a partner if I've ever seen one. Dylan did not want the Galz exile... but didn't want to be off wagon if it was going to happen.
Iguana reads as town to me. His defense against Pubby's post sounded more like a townie's defense, and a lot of my thoughts (not all, but a lot) have been mirrored in things they've said before I manage to get on and catch up, so that seems townie to me. I agree that the GID theory is probably wrong on the whole, but I remember being in some games as town where I thought I had figured out the scum team really early and it can be hard to shake that thought, so I don't necessarily think Pubby is scum for trying to prove his case.
D2 now... and this really looks like a partner indication to pubby.