Sorry, this is going to be long! I'm finally on the laptop and able to track my thoughts a bit better.
The brighty/ pubby pair is powerful!! Beware!
Thanks for the heads-up... I haven't played with either before.
I never tag, but something told me I should post once in this thread.
What told you to post in the thread? The fact that you're actually in this game? Joth hasn't PINL that you're not in the game!
Most of the gamer dudes are going to have picked obscure dwarves I’ve never heard of. My not gamer friendlies will have chosen Disney dwarves or other popular culture ones like LoTR and whatnot.
I am the most obvious dwarf, or maybe second most obvious dwarf had I been thinking about it more.
Well, since I'm not a "gamer dude" (even though "dude" is in "mathdude") - are you making an assumption about the character I picked?
Also, are you trying to tell us who you picked? Is it helpful for us to know? Anyone who knows Didds, what would be the "most obvious dwarf, or maybe second most obvious dwarf"?
MiX has been modkilled. He was Not Playing.
Why did you have to kill MiX? Turned up green - we could have used one more Town player.
He did not PINL MiX is not playing = MiX IS playing.
He did not PINL his Modkill was real = MiX is alive.
He did not PINL MiX is Green = MiX is red.
MiX also dodged my question on why he’s not scum this game.
Join me in exiling MiX.
This is reasonable logic. If we do end up heading towards a no-exile, I will switch my vote over to help you exile MiX to make sure he's not in this game!
I'm trying to come up with a list of potentially evil dwarf characters but all I can think of is Mini Me and that tiny dude in Elf. Any more?
So... come up with a list of evil names, then ask everyone to flavour-claim, and use that to choose who to vote for? Seems like you should have kept this list secret until after the flavour-claim. Or are you Scum, giving advice to other Scum not to claim their evil dwarf names if/when you do ask us all to claim?
Also I have it on good authority that not PINL != PIL.
And what is this good authority? Did Joth actually confirm to you with PINL? Or are you making it up for your own nefarious purposes?
Hey uh Didds, did you get your alignment with PINL?
Did you get yours with PINL?
Oh that's right, Mafia. I've decided to swear off RVS and vote only when I mean it. Vote: Brightgalrs
Right now, those statements contradict each other to me... no RVS generally means there's a reason, but you give no reason. I don't know you or Bright... so why do you have a reason to vote Bright?
I don't have any pets.
You could get a cat. Cats are awesome.
But I've never liked pickles.
Is there a history here that I don't know about? Or is this a weird part of your role?
Please tell me that we get fun memes with every vote count (and you better PINL your response!)
Galzria (1): Awaclus
This is a pretty promising and towny wagon, I think I'm going to join it too!
Vote: Galzria
I would say this looks odd, and ash-like. But I get the feeling (with my limited exposure to your posts) that this is Awaclus-like too.
This is a pretty promising and towny wagon, I think I'm going to join it too!
Vote: Galzria
^^
vote: Galzria
However, this looks really scummy to me. Ride along behind Awaclus?
- Didds seems the most likely to pick a happy Disney dwarf or Smurf
- Joth seems the most likely to make the happiest dwarf the most evil dwarf
- Therefore Didds is evil
What a good theory.
Ok, I'm starting to see that Bright-pubby combination mentioned earlier (first quote of this post, I believe)... are they always playing off each other? Should I keep a closer eye on this?
Vote: WCD
Here's the logic:
- Didds seems the most likely to pick a happy Disney dwarf or Smurf
- Joth seems the most likely to make the happiest dwarf the most evil dwarf
- Therefore Didds is evil
QED
This is a good theory.
Vote: pubby
Pasta, are you defending Didds?
Nope! 100% NOT EVIL! PINL
This is scummy. Needing to say you're not evil is a scum-tell in my experience.
I still stand by the idea that he did NOT kill MiX.
But Scola is a better place to find scum than MiX.
You should join me in exiling Scola. It’s what Good Dwarves do.
Vote: scolapasta
I was told it's what Good Dwarves do. But what do Good Dwarfs do?
Vote: Galzria
There's something weird going on here. I'm just flagging it for my own future reference - some interaction that I'm going to keep an eye on.
A Good Dwarf doesn’t need to ask what Good Dwarves do.
He didn't. He asked what Good Dwarfs do.
You provided the information about what Good Dwarves do entirely unsolicited. Now, if, as you say, that information is not needed by a Good Dwarf, did you provide it to help a Bad Dwarf?
... and it continues. (Again, just collecting these ideas, more for my future reference, but also so others can help me learn whether interactions like this are common for these pairs or whether this is something that stands out).
I stand corrected on Dwarves vs Dwarfs. Entirely my fault.
As for offering advice to Bad Dwarf's, it's entirely possible that I did. Do you think that WCD is a Bad Dwarf? My advice, while unsolicited, was entirely pro-town.
Do you think WCD is a Bad Dwarf?
Also, as I mentioned earlier about Didds... saying that your post was "entirely pro-town" really looks like a scum-tell to me. Why do you feel the need to highlight your own "Towniness"?
@Didds. Why are you voting for EFHW?
I tunneled her all game in the one that just concluded (conference call) and we lost so hard. Not just because of me, but I wasn't really helping matters at all. Mea culpa.
And you're repeating it this game so that we know you must be town again?
I didn't notice this in Didds's quoted statements there. But are you reading "I'm Town... see, I'm Town" vibes? Or are you trying to help Didds prove they are Town?
PPE... I think 12 new posts it says? I'm post this now and I'll go look at them shortly.
Author
Topic: BM32: All Dwarves are Bastards Mafia - GAME OVER PERFECT SCUM WIN (Read 106909 times)