Dylan is scum
Vote: Dylan
Let's go let's go everyone needs to vote for dylan right now before scum quickhammers and wins!
What? Well, this is an exciting start to the day. I'm just confused because this doesn't make any sense from cylon-aligned!MiX to force a 1v1 like this. He's definitely wrong, but this makes me think there might be a separate 3rd party faction that he and maybe ADK are in together or something... That or something was able to screw with the results you got.
I should probably talk more so people think I'm town beyond a shadow of a doubt. That includes you, ash! One wrong vote and this game could end horribly. It's possible we're not in XiLo though.
So, ADK was right: one of the civilians was scum. This makes me feel really good about him, as he's the one that told me to pick Dylan, and I only learned Dylan was scum because he was my vice-president. This also indicates that ADK was not cylon-aligned as I never learned his alignment when they were vice-president, but that's a stretch: I think my information grew in power in a reasonable proportion, so it might've not made sense to say what alignment ADK was before today.
I've also learned what character Dylan is, but not directly: the flavor implied Dylan is Caprica Six. So that would be a civilian, which makes what ADK was saying.
Let's look at the other piece of info I know: Jack's wagon.
"Jack Rudd (6): MiX, WestCoastDidds, A Drowned Kernel, scolapasta, EFHW, SpaceAnemone"
Me and ADK are...well, we're not cylon-aligned, by what I said above. So there's scum in (Didds, scola, EFHW, Space). Given what went down yesterday, I would put scum in (scola, EFHW). Didds is right: she's town. And Space would have to be aligned with Robz, I think. Then again, my reads aren't that good, I only started scumreading Dylan yesterday after he used the question the way Space wanted. I'll have to reread Dylan now.
There is an odd number of cylon-aligned players in {MiX, Space, LaLight, Jack, Didds}.
This is Dylan's question now, which has a different meaning now that he's scum. You can read it however you want, but personally I think it's bogus: chances are the real answer is even, but that's what I think anyway (they're all town), and he could've easily told the truth. I'm just posting it here for who wants to scum hunt this way (also note that LL died and is in this group: this supports my theory of 0 scum here).
Can't think of anything else that's relevant right now.
The first person to get on the thread should do the test, most likely.
I think EFHW specifically has to do the test, unless we're all so certain she's a cylon that we move onto the next-most-suspicious person?
As evidence, LL was town, so was telling the truth about being able to detect cylons. He knew EFHW targeted him D1, so previously I thought either she must have been a cylon, or LL was lying. With LL's flip, we at least need to hear from EFHW about why she thinks that is. We've already seen on human-aligned cylon in the form of Boomer, so I'm pretty sceptical about the existence of a second, as opposed to actual cylon-aligned cylons.
Yes, but I think the day will end before we can coordinate. Any result would be helpful right now: I think the scum aligned humans are either town (Baltar) or not human at all (Dylan).
This is absurd. The urgency that town is so close to losing feels extremely manufactured to me, because MiX has been carrying on like this for like 2 days already. So you're basing all your actions on literally claimed 3rd party as the basis for how you play? Let me say it for the fans in the back, THAT'S NOT TOWNY. Wait, and you allegedly got information about me you weren't getting on other VPs? This is nonsense. And now you are making up speculation on my flavor? Tom Zarek is a civilian, and while he seems like a very conflicted dude based on the wiki, the one thing he wasn't was cylon-aligned. I don't have any idea who Caprica 6 is, so I can't even pretend to know what you could be pulling out of your rear end to come up with that.
You then ignore the actual final Jack wagon: "Jack Rudd (5): SpaceAnemone, EFHW, WestCoastDidds, Robz888, Dylan32"
"Me and ADK are...well, we're not cylon-aligned, by what I said above."
You can't even bring yourself to say your town? I'm not even going to engage with your wagon analysis because you're just making crap up now.
100% vote Dylan today, there's really no decision here. These past few days have been about deciding if I'm town or not, and now is the time where you decide that, yes, I am town.
EFHW's a probably cylon, but we can do that tomorrow.
I am strongly leaning towards voting Dylan here. I think either town MiX or Survivor Mix would be telling the truth. But as we agree that we don't have the immediate rush, want to give some time to still mull it over, ask some more questions, and let players report what night time things they may have done. Otherwise my vote would put a curfewed Dylan at X-1 and I don't think we're there yet, especially with a hammering Ash.
But at the moment, I'm @ it's Dylan today, and if he's not actually scum, you tomorrow. Otherwise EFHW.
Please stop trying to imply that scum wants you to do what scum tells you to do. If I'm scum, the last thing I expect people to do is vote Dylan when I say so. You should be more willing to vote for someone I am conflicting, not less.
Sure, except for WIFOM, so good scum would know to do both.
ADK should probably not say more but like who cares, they were right. Even if you think I'm scum. So does it matter?
It does matter, but I'm not yet ready to reveal more now.
So some other questions: what were the other orders you could've chosen? Why did you choose so fast? If you are scum Mix trying to get us down to 7 (due to 4 scum), it would definitely make sense to protect yourself if you're worried a vig shot would take you out at night. And we've only flipped one killing power which was passive, so there definitely could be a vig out there still. And yes, there are also reasons for town Mix to choose that order to, so choosing it doesn't automatically imply scum or survivor Mix.
So care to enlighten us some more on your decision process there?
Not going into why right now, but my gut says this is scummy.