I've been following through a few hypotheticals:
If ADK is scum:
1. Busses Galz really early (3rd post of the game), and stays there in spite of Galz becoming an early bigest wagon at 3 votes while nobody else had more than 1 for much of that time.
2. Was the last to leave the early Galz wagon, after Raptor and faust had moved their votes elsewhere.
3. Moves briefly to Dylan, then to mcmc, where they end the day not on the Galz wagon.
4. D2, spends most of the day on gkrieg, beore moving to LL in the X-1 position when the exile looked inevitable.
5. Opens D3 going back to gkrieg, not even really acknowledging any of the extra info the 3 intervening flips gave us.
If MiX is scum:
1. Spends most of D1 on mcmc from as early as #42, which was only the 12th post of the whole game.
2. Moves off a three-person mcmc wagon (the leading alternative to the 5-person Galz wagon) to bus LL at #203.
3. Moves back to mcmc at #220 to end D1 there, with a lot of arguing about why exiling Galz is a bad idea.
4. Spends almost all of D2 on EFHW, with a slight blip of unvoting from #426 to #429. Motable that MiX says at #426 mcmc-vs-LL looks like town-v-town though.
5. Joins the LL wagon at X-2 at #448, where Raptor hammers at #468. (EFHW and I were also around and stating willingness to vote, from scum's perspective, byt the time X-2 happened, LL was basically going to get exiled, so being x-2 rather than X-1 isn't any less scummy really).
If Didds is scum:
1. Took a long time to commit to any wagon. Finally voted for scum!Galz when mcmc and I were both on three votes each and I had a protest vote on Didds herself. I just don't see scum!Didds going for a needless bus there when there were good voting possibilities.
2. She's around and engages in discussion about why an absent-Galz exile is okay, and also about who to look to for a sub, but ultimately doesn't use any of that as an excuse to move her vote, even though her suggestion of asking Joth or Glooble to sub happens at #219, when Galz was on 5 votes.
3. In fact, LL joins the Galz wagon at #202, because presumably it looked inevitable for scum by then. If LL and Didds have instead moved to Mcmc, the wagons would be level, which would have been way better for scum.
4. Didds was on a 5-person town!mcmc wagon in D2, but when that shrank to 4, she moved onto third place on the scum!LL wagon, and then stayed there all through the exile.
Well, Didds just doesn't look like scum here at all to me. MiX looks pretty scummy again, especially with the Galz-defending D1 and the throwaway town-v-town comment D2. He was also very willing to join me quickly on ADK in the D3 voting, which set off a little alarm bell for me. So yeah, it's MiX or ADK.