Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EFHW]

I will say that Joth has been acting slightly more townie in private than he has in the main thread.

Not much, but enough that I found it worth mentioning.

The main issue I am having is that both versions of a Joth would be frustrated at Ash right now.

I guess I feel pretty confident that Ash and Joth ain’t scum buddies, but that’s it.

Can you say more about how joth is being towny?

[jotheonah]

How does Roleblocker fit with your flavor?

Roleblockers have been flavored as prostitutes from the early days of mafia. I think the idea is that they distract the target for the night. If you search prostitute on mafiascum wiki it redirects to roleblocker.

[ashersky]

Roleblocker is also, of course, a popular anti-town role for anti-town alignments.  Town versions exist, which make them a go-to claim for mafia.

Just pointing that out.

[ashersky]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

[jotheonah]

Roleblocker is also, of course, a popular anti-town role for anti-town alignments.  Town versions exist, which make them a go-to claim for mafia.

Just pointing that out.

Believe me, if I were scum I would have claimed doctor or something else undeniably towny. Unfortunately I'm town and have to claim my real role.

[jotheonah]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

Ok. So far you've done absolutely nothing protown this game. Day one you did a bunch of setup talk, which is easy peezy acti-lurking, and today you've done nothing but your lazy, preposterous manufactured 1v1 on me.

[EFHW]

joth, who would you exile other than ashersky?

[ashersky]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

Ok. So far you've done absolutely nothing protown this game. Day one you did a bunch of setup talk, which is easy peezy acti-lurking, and today you've done nothing but your lazy, preposterous manufactured 1v1 on me.

I disagree that what I've done has not been protown.  I agree with your Day 1 assessment.  The 1v1 may be manufactured, but definitely not lazy.  It's a lot of work!

[jotheonah]

joth, who would you exile other than ashersky?

In this timeline or in either timeline?

[Uncleeurope]

I will say that Joth has been acting slightly more townie in private than he has in the main thread.

Not much, but enough that I found it worth mentioning.

The main issue I am having is that both versions of a Joth would be frustrated at Ash right now.

I guess I feel pretty confident that Ash and Joth ain’t scum buddies, but that’s it.

Can you say more about how joth is being towny?

Eh, his interactions with me have been minimal, but his frustration seems genuine.

But it’s hard to say.

He seems bewildered as to how I (or anyone) could possibly see Ash as Townier than him.

It’s hard to say, I haven’t had the best track record at reading Joth.

He also did claim to be a scummy role to me few days ago, so his fakeclaim was either figured out days ago, or it isn’t fake.

I honestly can’t make heads or tails of him.

I scum leaned him day 1, but his posts to me directly have left me closer to null.

Make of that what you will.

I find value in at least setting up some cases for others today.

[Uncleeurope]

(Well, his fakeclaim If definitely not fake)

(But is an escort really town aligned? Ehh...)

[Swowl]

Vote Count 2.5:

Joth (3): WCD, EFHW, Ashersky
Ashersky (2): Joth, scolapasta
WestCoastDidds (1): Dylan32

Not Voting (: Galzria, MiX, Eddie, chairs, hypercube, Glooble, PPS, Awaclus

With 7 alive on the ACTIVE TIMELINE, it takes 4 to Exile.
Day 2 ends Tuesday, May 18th at 4:55pm Forum Time - That is less than 2 days from now.

Today the active timeline is the FORWARD TIMELINE We will remain in the FORWARD TIMELINE until the start of Day 3.
Only players from the currently active timeline may vote, or be voted for.

[ashersky]

If anyone was asking me, I would say Galzria is the other option for today.

And I say that with a heavy heart, of course.  But man, talk about inactive.  Town!galz is just much more active than this usually.

[Awaclus]

MFW not voting:

[Glooble]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

I did make a point that everyone ignored, so I’ll say it again- putting joth to E-1 and saying it was E-2 was scummy. What’s your defense of that?

[Glooble]

He seems bewildered as to how I (or anyone) could possibly see Ash as Townier than him.

Honestly, same. I’m incredibly bewildered that we haven’t already exiled ash.

[Glooble]

I’d also like EFHW to respond to my earlier accusation towards her.

[pingpongsam]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

I did make a point that everyone ignored, so I’ll say it again- putting joth to E-1 and saying it was E-2 was scummy. What’s your defense of that?

This ignores the E-1 elephant that's been standing in the room for some time now. Diverting from that is far scummier.

[Glooble]

I'd like to invite joth (and any other players who would like) to continue to try to make a case, any case, that I am not town.  It's super hilarious.  I get why many may not understand why, but it is.

I did make a point that everyone ignored, so I’ll say it again- putting joth to E-1 and saying it was E-2 was scummy. What’s your defense of that?

This ignores the E-1 elephant that's been standing in the room for some time now. Diverting from that is far scummier.

I literally don’t understand what you’re saying here.

[Glooble]

Also Roleblocker is a weird fakeclaim to make as scum, especially given joth’s position today. Why wouldn’t he claim something really good and at least try to bait out a counterclaim?

[WestCoastDidds]

Hmmm...  if there are two baddies on our timeline, and it takes 4 to exile, then we (town) pretty much all need to be on the same page to make that happen.

That Joth has been cold chilling at E-1 for like a day now is interesting in that regard. In the last game I played when someone couldn’t get exiled, it was because they were scum. Glooble leanibg way in to defend Joth is interesting to me, too.

I’m not quite sure what up make of Dylan’s vote for me, or Galz’s absence. Absent Galz is often scum Galz. Do we know who his qt-mate is? Has he shown up there? The odds of no exile go way up if someone just stays away, but that seems to suit scum way better than town as long as we’re in split timelines.

I’m heading back to the States this afternoon. I think I’ll have WiFi for most of that time so I should be around more.

[EFHW]

joth, who would you exile other than ashersky?

In this timeline or in either timeline?

This one

[EFHW]

I’d also like EFHW to respond to my earlier accusation towards her.

Didn't realize you were that serious. I didn't notice the E2/E1 issue until you pointed it out.

[Glooble]

I’d also like EFHW to respond to my earlier accusation towards her.

Didn't realize you were that serious. I didn't notice the E2/E1 issue until you pointed it out.

Interesting. I don't buy it. When you voted for joth, you had to have known how many votes were already on him. When you saw ash's vote and subsequent incorrect vote count, how could you not have noticed an error?

[Glooble]

If I could vote right now, I would have just moved my vote from ash to EFHW. Because if ash v. joth is town v. town, then scum!EFHW not pointing out ash's error makes a lot more sense to me than town!EFHW just not noticing. And if ash is scum and joth is town, same thing. It becomes a concerted ploy to trick a townie into hammering while thinking they're just putting joth to E-1. And if they're caught "oh, sorry, we just didn't notice, we made a mistake."

Well, I'll buy one player of their caliber making that mistake. But both? For 16 hours? No, sorry.