Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[skip wooznum]

@Joseph, if faust is the only scum left, it doesn't matter what you do, we have majority without you.

If faust is telling the truth, and there's another scum, your best option is to lynch faust today. If you vote no lynch, the game ends tonight. There's no way to know they're telling the truth and that they'll give you all pieces tonight. Better to lynch faust, make them give you a piece tonight, plus you steal one tonight, then tomorrow you steal the last piece. The game goes longer if you lynch faust. Longer is better for you.

[faust]

What skip said would be true, except I have all the pieces. I would take you 3 nights to graverob them, and no matter how the game goes, you don't have three nights. So you need me to give and one and pawnbroker another one tonight.

[faust]

I've been thinking about winning with town here actually... if I could get my hands on the codebook, I'd presumably leave the game. But the codebook is in Joseph's hands, and they have no interest in giving it to me. So unfortunately, I don't think that is going to be an option.

[skip wooznum]

Do you have a teammate? What is happening?

[skip wooznum]

What skip said would be true, except I have all the pieces. I would take you 3 nights to graverob them, and no matter how the game goes, you don't have three nights. So you need me to give and one and pawnbroker another one tonight.

you can't give and pawn on the same night tho

[faust]

What skip said would be true, except I have all the pieces. I would take you 3 nights to graverob them, and no matter how the game goes, you don't have three nights. So you need me to give and one and pawnbroker another one tonight.

you can't give and pawn on the same night tho

Everyone may pass 1 item to another player at night in addition to any other night actions.

[skip wooznum]

If you were four scum to start, why not just give Joseph the owl two days, and then town wouldn't have majority? You'd have won by D4.

Please just tell me you're trolling. You don't know what this is doing to me.

For real.

[faust]

If you were four scum to start, why not just give Joseph the owl two days, and then town wouldn't have majority? You'd have won by D4.

Please just tell me you're trolling. You don't know what this is doing to me.

For real.

We were worried that Joseph was hiding something, so we tried to win on our own terms. We thought if we get all the owl pieces we might activate some sort of special power to help us achieve that. Now we have them all but cannot use them, so turns out we need Joseph after all.

[skip wooznum]

If you were four scum to start, why not just give Joseph the owl two days ago, and then town wouldn't have majority? You'd have won by D4.

Please just tell me you're trolling. You don't know what this is doing to me.

For real.

[skip wooznum]

I suppose you let us lynch mail-mi yesterday because you wanted to see what would happen if you got the third piece, right?

[skip wooznum]

I'm going to sleep.

If there really is a fourth scum, this game is dumb.

Remind me never to play a closed setup again.

[faust]

Well it was labeled bastard.

I will say that the design kind of didn't do either faction many favor. It feels bad for town because of how many scum there are. It feels bad for scum because we're forced into multiple 1v1 situation without our knowledge. It may have been balanced in the end, but I think it feels frustrating for both sides.

[Joseph2302]

Shame, all that.

Vote: No Lynch

Joseph, we have all the owl pieces. If you vote with us, we're willing to give them to you. We can give you 2 pieces, and you can steal the third from me tonight.

Or you can lose. If I am lynched, then for sure you won't have time to recover all the pieces before the game is over.

"With us"- there's more than 1 scum left?

[Joseph2302]

Vote: No lynch

[Joseph2302]

Faust, is it you that I need to steal from tonight?

[faust]

Faust, is it you that I need to steal from tonight?

Yes.

[A Drowned Kernel]

vote: no lynch

[scolapasta]

Huh, lots happened while I was away. Joseph not sure why you voted no lynch before we could even discuss, but oh well, ADK is 3 votes, right? So it's done.

And people thought I was scum over faust. Sigh.

[Glooble]

Five people stood around the bar, a far cry from the angry mobs of nights past.

“Should we kill someone tonight?” asked the bartender.

“Nah,” said the others.

Faust (1): skip wooznum
No Lynch (3): faust, Joseph2302, A Drowned Kernel
Not voting (1): scolapasta

With 5 alive, it took 3 to not lynch!

No one has died! Night 6 has begun. It will end at 10:30 pm on Wednesday, May 27th, or sooner if everyone agrees.

THREAD LOCKED

[Glooble]

That night Natalia and the Russian appeared outside the tent where I was hiding. They dropped a burlap sack on the ground next to me.

“You can have this,” said Natalia. “Turns out we didn’t need it after all. We control the town now. I suggest you take your trinket and get out.”

The owl was in the bag.

I was on a plane that night. The mob was running this town now, and I needed to be anywhere else.

skip wooznum has died. He was the Town Sailor.

scolapasta has been endgamed. The mafia team of Jotheonah, Faust, mail-mi and A Drowned Kernel has won. Joseph2303, the Treasure Hunter has also won.

Scum: https://www.quicktopic.com/53/H/ZSBNrVaB9MD4

Speccy: https://www.quicktopic.com/53/H/XwvmwpFugBQVZ


Thank you all for playing. I apologize for all of the mod errors and glaring design flaws.

[skip wooznum]

And people thought I was scum over faust. Sigh.

To be fair, you thought I was scum for most of the game, which I think is more impressive.

[mail-mi]

gg y'all!

Glooble, I think the game was fun! There will always be some errors.

I hope you mod again.

[scolapasta]

And people thought I was scum over faust. Sigh.

To be fair, you thought I was scum for most of the game, which I think is more impressive.

True. In my (weak?) defense it was more of a "one of you or mail-mi" and thought you were the more likely of the two. If we had lynched you and mail-mi D1 and D2, this would've been a very different game.

[MiX]

And people thought I was scum over faust. Sigh.

To be fair, you thought I was scum for most of the game, which I think is more impressive.

You were definitely scum, with your...uh...townieness, and your...better position in the 1v1...and...uh...yeah no you were town I'm sorry.

Town really dropped the ball this game. Sucks that I helped us with this.

[skip wooznum]

Aight just finished with the speccy.

To those who like me, your comments are appreciated, and I like you too

And yes, as was pointed out in the speccy, in retrospect, the correct play D5 would be to get Joseph to quicklynch faust before faust could get online and negotiate. (And it probably would have worked too, what with Joseph being super mad at scum for needlessly stealing from him both nights.) It's just that in my mind there was no way adk was mafia, I didn't even consider the possibility. Forgetting the balance issues of having 4 scum (which have been debated already and I don't want to get into it), there was also the fact that yesterday we very slowly and very deliberately lynched mafia, which is impossible to do if there isn't a town majority. So I was 100% convinced that the game was in the bag. I just thought it would be amusing to see what wild story faust would concoct to try to get out of the lynch (borderline bad sportsmanship but I was really excited for the win). Well, I guess I learned something.