Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Xxraptorslayer96]

I like the case on Mix, I don't mind voting there obvi. but would still rather lynch Dylan because I know that he is 100% lying.

lol k

Vote: Raptor


you're up slugger

LOL Is this me L-1?  annoying.

swan - do you find me scummy or just a better lynch for town?

[MiX]

That's L-1

Do your magic ash. I'm a bit tired of this day, but if it got raptor lynched, then it was worth it.

[Dylan32]

Also, to Ash's questioning my reply to raptor's claimed motivations, the fact that the UB might convert to a mason is even more reason not to hold onto the shot. Sure there probably is a UB most of the time, but I just think you're better off using it.  Until people claim, the odds are that there's probably a better PR out there for the UB to pick up than your 1-shot power, so using it and claiming it early to reduce the odds scum NKs you would boost the odds the UB picks up a better PR than yours, so I don't think raptor's idea of saving it for the UB is good even if it were possible that he was town.

ppe 2

You have to admit that it's possible for town to think like raptor, right? So it doesn't make him scum.

Honestly, in the scenario we had in D1, I just don't see town not protecting the cop unless you didn't believe the claim. Raptor has given no indication that he didn't believe it, even though he's had several chances, and in fact his comments suggest he did believe it, and so no, I don't believe town would have held the shot there at all. In different situations and other games, sure, but here, I wouldn't buy it even if I wasn't the one who was 1v1 with him.

Hmm, people can do strange things...I wouldn't had doctored shraeye, for example. You have to accept that others don't follow the same logic as you, and it doesn't inherently make them scummy. Of course this is a bad example, since you know he's scum, but...it can happen.

Look at me and ash. He's hellbent that I wouldn't do what I did as town. Yet I did. He would never do what I did as town, in his mind what happened is impossible for town to do, yet I did it. And I've played a bunch of games with ash and he's modded some more, he knows me. What you believe people will do in certain situations is not what they will 100% do in those situations.

Also, you have to consider that in this game, scum absolutely believed the claim enough to warrant shooting them N1. Combine that with the evidence that Raptor believed the claim, and it makes him marginally more likely to be scum, even ignoring the PR claiming stuff. Of course town could have believed the claim too, so I don't pretend that's conclusive, but it's another detail that lines up well with scum!raptor.

Weak. There's better arguments for his scummyness. Whoever didn't believe shraeye is scum, because scum knows there couldn't be any full Cop, is an argument that I could make as well and it would be just as bad. Also scum would say they didn't fully believe shraeye because of what you just said, so WIFOM.

Actually, what did YOU think of shraeye throughout this game?

Assuming throughout the game you mean D1 since that's all they had, I was pretty null. Before the flip, I think I liked the play more than I disliked it, and with hindsight obviously I loved it.  But with my role I thought it was statistically more likely to be a lie than true, but definitely thought it was possible. Without going back and reading, I don't remember much else of what they said.

ppe 4

[Swowl]

I like the case on Mix, I don't mind voting there obvi. but would still rather lynch Dylan because I know that he is 100% lying.

lol k

Vote: Raptor


you shouldn't want to or care about lynching mix at all. if you are town the only person ever. ever. that you should be ok with gunning after today is Dylan.
Opening doors to other players is an out.

you're up slugger

LOL Is this me L-1?  annoying.

swan - do you find me scummy or just a better lynch for town?

[Swowl]

I like the case on Mix, I don't mind voting there obvi. but would still rather lynch Dylan because I know that he is 100% lying.

lol k

Vote: Raptor


you're up slugger

LOL Is this me L-1?  annoying.

swan - do you find me scummy or just a better lynch for town?

FIXED.

you shouldn't want to or care about lynching mix at all. if you are town the only person ever. ever. that you should be ok with gunning after today is Dylan.
Opening doors to other players is an out.

[Xxraptorslayer96]

That's L-1

Do your magic ash. I'm a bit tired of this day, but if it got raptor lynched, then it was worth it.

Don't tell people how to live their life, its bad manners.

[Xxraptorslayer96]

I like the case on Mix, I don't mind voting there obvi. but would still rather lynch Dylan because I know that he is 100% lying.

lol k

Vote: Raptor

you're up slugger

LOL Is this me L-1?  annoying.

swan - do you find me scummy or just a better lynch for town?

FIXED.

you shouldn't want to or care about lynching mix at all. if you are town the only person ever. ever. that you should be ok with gunning after today is Dylan.
Opening doors to other players is an out.

Dylan and Mix are one in the same at this point to me. Do me a favor and lynch Mix after Dylan flips tomorrow.

[Swowl]

That's L-1

Do your magic ash. I'm a bit tired of this day, but if it got raptor lynched, then it was worth it.

Don't tell people how to live their life, its bad manners.

i love you so much sometimes lol. but you're still skum.

[Swowl]

That's L-1

Do your magic ash. I'm a bit tired of this day, but if it got raptor lynched, then it was worth it.

also thank you for this. I assumed my back and forth with Ash made it clear, but yes this is L-1.

[MiX]

Dylan and Mix are one in the same at this point to me. Do me a favor and lynch Mix after Dylan flips tomorrow.

I guess you can flip town. But how am I scum, again? I forgot where you said why you believe I was scum, which I asked for a clarification a bit back.

[Dylan32]

I'm going offline and don't know what's going to happen re: hammer or nah, so I just want to make a note since the 3rd scum would have no reason to keep me alive once raptor goes down.

When I presented a case on yuma, his response was literally just that would be way to scummy for me to have actually done that.  If you had successfully pushed a lynch away from Joseph and let the heat die down on raptor as a result, it would have been great play, you just ran into a cop result that got the Joseph hammered pretty quickly and set the other up for some high heat (who then got himself into a 1v1). I'm not a believer in too-scummy-to-be-scum.

[Xxraptorslayer96]

I give up, town will still win this one, bummed that I won't be around for it to happen. cheers

PPE 4

[Dylan32]

I give up, town will still win this one, bummed that I won't be around for it to happen. cheers

PPE 4

Nice AtE. Lynching you will get town closer to winning, so yeah, cheers!

[MiX]

I'm going offline and don't know what's going to happen re: hammer or nah, so I just want to make a note since the 3rd scum would have no reason to keep me alive once raptor goes down.

When I presented a case on yuma, his response was literally just that would be way to scummy for me to have actually done that.  If you had successfully pushed a lynch away from Joseph and let the heat die down on raptor as a result, it would have been great play, you just ran into a cop result that got the Joseph hammered pretty quickly and set the other up for some high heat (who then got himself into a 1v1). I'm not a believer in too-scummy-to-be-scum.

Cya Dylan! Good night everyone else! Can't wait to wake up to the flip.

PPE 2: I can't stress how amusing I find these dying messages. From both of you.

[WestCoastDidds]

The only thing I love more than arguments are appeals to emotion.

xoxoxo

Let’s get going....

Vote: raptor

[Xxraptorslayer96]

Dylan and Mix are one in the same at this point to me. Do me a favor and lynch Mix after Dylan flips tomorrow.

I guess you can flip town. But how am I scum, again? I forgot where you said why you believe I was scum, which I asked for a clarification a bit back.

I think that you are scum because Dylans plan would not have come together the way that it did without you. TBH i also just naturally always scum read you, and you have done nothing to prove to me that you are town other than attack me. Also I did explain why I thought that you were Dylans partner in #556.

PPE 3

[Xxraptorslayer96]

Raptor out xoxo

[Swowl]

lynch ash next if we are right.

[WestCoastDidds]

That's L-1

Do your magic ash. I'm a bit tired of this day, but if it got raptor lynched, then it was worth it.

Don't tell people how to live their life, its bad manners.

lynch ash next if we are right.

Love it!

[yuma]

Dylan had just convinced me to vote: raptor but I'll do it anyway just to be sure.

[yuma]

But ash isn't scum.

[scolapasta]

So this is only my 2nd game on here, but Didds seems to be posting a lot less than in the last game. And/or her posts are more terse. Any particular reason for that?

[scolapasta]

If raptor scum, my shortlist is Ash, Mix, Didds, yuma (is that still short?) - not necessarily that order.

DatSwan was on list but you've convinced me finally.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Xxraptorslayer96 has been lynched! He was a Mafia Godfather!

Final Vote Count

XXraptorslayer96 (5): scolapasta, MiX, Dylan32, DatSwan, WestCoastDidds
MiX (1): ashersky
Dylan32 (3): LaLight, Xxraptorslayer96, yuma

With 9 alive it took 5 to lynch. Night Three begins now and ends at 12 an forum time April 25th.

[A Drowned Kernel]

THREAD LOCKED