Awaclus discarded Vengeful Townie
Better than VT, Awaclus has at least something that he deems better than Vengeful. I would think town is his favourite team, so the discard's pretty interesting. It's somewhat scummy but at the same time I don't think Awaclus would pick scum given the chance.
faust discarded Werewolf Miller
Well this just tells us nothing. Just about any role is better than scum miller.
pubby discarded Conspiracy Theorist
This is a good discard if you're picking alien. I think pubby would prefer to be scum than town based on how he's played, so I definitely think he picks any scum over a semi-miller. No idea if the role's better than the other town PRs.
e discarded Retired Werewolf Hunter
Werewolf-bulletproof isn't very good, but better than nothing. Not much else to say here, really, there's a lot of roles that are better than this.
MiX discarded Lynchbait
Is lynchbait good utility, negative utility or neutral? Looks like a VT that kills third-party in a blue moon.
Joseph2302 discarded Vanilla Towni
"Vanilla Towni" is one of those roles that everyone discards given a non-miller or something awful so it won't tell us much.
SpaceAnemone discarded Innocent Child
This is actually incredibly scummy. Why would space ever choose anything other than IC? I think we should force a claim here, but I reeeeally don't think space would pick scum knowing they would flip discarding IC. But why do the same as town? It doesn't make any sense to me.
WestCoastDidds discarded Underdog
Didds wants to win! I think that role would go along being nice, but it's pretty much a townie that doesn't play D1 so I can see Didds choosing not to be it if the other role isn't too bad.
Glooble discarded Mason Lover
Mason is great! Lover is not. I can see Glooble throwing this away for something even better, but honestly how many people pick Lover for it to be relevent? I'll give him a less emphasized FoS similar to joth, but this IS weaker than mason.
pingpongsam discarded One-Shot Unlynchable Townie
You're scum right? Abilities that let you stay in the game for longer make sense for a fun setup with 23 players. I think pps would personally choose other PRs over this, so given it's pps I don't think it matters much.
DatSwan discarded Nurse
Eh, discarded a role better than VT, but not by much.
sudgy discarded Werewolf
Well this doesn't say much, other than he could've gotten 2 scum and had no choice. Just about anything could be preferable to being a goon-
Brightgalrs discarded Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Townie
Probably the worst role after Black Goo, everyone discards this over whatever else they have.
mail-mi discarded Hirsute Townie
Discarding miller is rational as anyone.
jotheonah discarded Mason
I talked about this: what PR's better than mason? Also see how joth and Glooble could've been masons! It's a very scummy flip, but unlike IC (like Space) I think you could talk your way out of it. Which makes it scummier, I suppose.
Uncleeurope discarded Mafia Goon
Goon's bad! Tells us that maybe he didn't have a choice?
Galzria discarded Bodyguard
Anti-fun role in a 23 player setup, I would've discarded this like it's a miller, so doesn't say much.
shraeye discarded Compulsive Childkiller
This role's better than it looks, but even then, mafia day-vig can fakeclaim this to justify killing an IC, which probably makes this sorta miller. So I understand the discard over almost anything.
EFHW discarded Alien One-Shot Unlynchable
Town or a very very fun role. EFHW is my IC. If you want to be scum, you always pick the unlynchable. The flip might just look super town if you were picking between scum I suppose.
LaLight discarded Lyncher (target player below)
Choosing to win sounds correct. Having to lynch Eevee is most likely harder than being town or scum.
Eevee discarded Vanilla Townie
Standard.
Raerae discarded Vanilla Townie
Run-of-the-mill.
Archetype discarded Mafia Reflexive Doctor
Bad scum role, is discarded by most.
Conclusions next post.
Author
Topic: BM27: Bad Idea Mafia- Game Over, Everyone Loses! (Read 170070 times)