so like
joth > Eevee > faust >>> Galzria > raerae > Maxford >>> Joseph > Space > raptor > Me
I'm okay with joth and faust being red. I want Eevee and you to be the same colour because of that comment of MiX's that he was getting confused between the two of you.. I think that means there's a high chance you're both just town.
I'm okay with Galz being yellow. Maxford is tough.. he's new and smart, and if he's scum he'll have good people like Joth and faust advising him, so it's not impossible he's scum. I think Joth's scumslip is most likely with Joth scum and Maxford town, though. This is another good reason to solve the game only after we get Joth's flip!
I do think Raerae is town, though. She's been doing a lot of townie sensible cautioning of people (right back to disliking my D1 pass-list), and like me, she was on MiX with similar justifications (I think?) from early D2, well before Raptor brought forth his evidence.
It's true that we don't know whether the scumteam was certain that MiX was their buddy, in which case Raerae could just have been voting MiX as a possible mislynch, but I like her questions about who Joth targeted N1, and the MiX answer definitely didn't seem to be crafted to help the scumteam... except possibly in the very unlikely world in which Joth isn't scum. Could we just agree to suspect Raerae more if Joth doesn't flip scum, and then get on with lynching him because he's actually scum?
PPE 1