Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

So what did you think of his Jester claim?

Not much? I think he would have done it as either alignment. I thought he was probably not the Lyncher for it.

[Galzria]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

That’s on my list. So is #628,#629 & #632.

Sorry, not #632 - I meant #634

[Swowl]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

That’s on my list. So is #628,#629 & #632.

Sorry, not #632 - I meant #634

Galz is literally the only player in this game that does not get to claim they did not read my Jester comment as sarcasm. Faust is close to it. I have barely played with MiX. Hint - it was sarcasm.

[Galzria]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

That’s on my list. So is #628,#629 & #632.

Sorry, not #632 - I meant #634

Galz is literally the only player in this game that does not get to claim they did not read my Jester comment as sarcasm. Faust is close to it. I have barely played with MiX. Hint - it was sarcasm.

Indeed, this is likely true enough - which is why it’s just a singular point of data, and not an incriminating statement.

[MiX]

Why are you not claiming? I wouldn't call that sarcasm but maybe, yeah.

[Galzria]

Why are you not claiming?

[chairs]

Why are you not claiming?

[Swowl]

Well tbh I didn't expect an answer from either faust or Galz, so 50% is a win and I kind of have no option at this point.
I think this is a mistake - but I also think there is a more than likely chance that Joth is skum, so I guess it almost weighs out.


Ari can't kill


I felt the best of my ability would be used to isolate players on the other large wagon after Joseph flipped town.
That would be Chairs, Galz, Ari, MiX.
As I have stated to infinity, I am town reading MiX.
The galz thing is kind of meta related, but I assumed if Galz was skum I would not wake up for Day 2 so I removed them.
That left Ari and Chairs.

I had to try to balance between there being one of either promoter, but not knowing which. In the end, I assumed that Ari was far more likely to be the challenged player than chairs, and if not still far more likely to be pursued in the following days than chairs.


If someone could unvote me to avoid an early hammer that would be bitchin. If I am going down, then whatever, but I have some notes I want to compile and post before that happens.

[MiX]

Ari? Okay...

When are you finished with your next big post?

[Swowl]

Ari? Okay...

When are you finished with your next big post?

when you finish with your small annoying ones

[Swowl]

Ari? Okay...

When are you finished with your next big post?

when you finish with your small annoying ones

too crass... I apologize. Just frustrated with the situation.

[Swowl]

Ari? Okay...

When are you finished with your next big post?

when you finish with your small annoying ones

too crass... I apologize. Just frustrated with the situation.

It is the middle of the night here. I will get it out tomorrow morning/afternoon.

[faust]

If someone could unvote me to avoid an early hammer that would be bitchin. If I am going down, then whatever, but I have some notes I want to compile and post before that happens.

I think you have stalled the game just enough.

[Galzria]

Faust, thoughts on 628/629/634?

If Swan is scum, he doesn’t know if we’re top left or bottom right, which is consistent with those posts - and would also cause an unknown number of Bodyguards. If Swan is Psychologist, then he should’ve known that top left wasn’t an option, and that there could not be two bodyguards.

So - honest mistake or scum indicative inconsistency?

[faust]

Faust, thoughts on 628/629/634?

If Swan is scum, he doesn’t know if we’re top left or bottom right, which is consistent with those posts - and would also cause an unknown number of Bodyguards. If Swan is Psychologist, then he should’ve known that top left wasn’t an option, and that there could not be two bodyguards.

So - honest mistake or scum indicative inconsistency?

What do you think?

[faust]

unvote

[Swowl]

Faust, thoughts on 628/629/634?

If Swan is scum, he doesn’t know if we’re top left or bottom right, which is consistent with those posts - and would also cause an unknown number of Bodyguards. If Swan is Psychologist, then he should’ve known that top left wasn’t an option, and that there could not be two bodyguards.

So - honest mistake or scum indicative inconsistency?

neither. check my other other set up posts. I made sure to hide my identity in all of them. (play dumb if you would)

OK now I am going to bed

[Swowl]

ah ppe.
unless people are here and want to talk?

I got like 20 minutes before I literally pass out.

[Galzria]

Faust, thoughts on 628/629/634?

If Swan is scum, he doesn’t know if we’re top left or bottom right, which is consistent with those posts - and would also cause an unknown number of Bodyguards. If Swan is Psychologist, then he should’ve known that top left wasn’t an option, and that there could not be two bodyguards.

So - honest mistake or scum indicative inconsistency?

What do you think?

The latter.

I don’t like lynching the only Psychologist claim though. Makes me really uncomfortable. But if he’s scum then the real Psychologist staying quiet here is 100% the correct play.

[Swowl]

Faust, thoughts on 628/629/634?

If Swan is scum, he doesn’t know if we’re top left or bottom right, which is consistent with those posts - and would also cause an unknown number of Bodyguards. If Swan is Psychologist, then he should’ve known that top left wasn’t an option, and that there could not be two bodyguards.

So - honest mistake or scum indicative inconsistency?

What do you think?

The latter.

I don’t like lynching the only Psychologist claim though. Makes me really uncomfortable. But if he’s scum then the real Psychologist staying quiet here is 100% the correct play.

this is 99% of the reason I didn't want to claim - because I knew this would be the mindset

[Galzria]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

So what did you think of his Jester claim?

Circling back to this, this is a big point I had marking Joth as scum - it’s a claim that discourages people from lynching him that he would know he could make without being countered - and he could judge reactions to try and guess at which town bloc was rolled - as there could potentially be upwards of four town players that knew this claim to be untrue.

[MiX]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

So what did you think of his Jester claim?

Circling back to this, this is a big point I had marking Joth as scum - it’s a claim that discourages people from lynching him that he would know he could make without being countered - and he could judge reactions to try and guess at which town bloc was rolled - as there could potentially be upwards of four town players that knew this claim to be untrue.

You're hitting every point of why I thought he was scum D1. But Psychologist claim is just...soooo convenient. How would it be 4?

[Galzria]

This early D1 post is the final piece of the puzzle:

2) Joth is def the Jester.

A Psychologist would know that there is no Jester.

So what did you think of his Jester claim?

Circling back to this, this is a big point I had marking Joth as scum - it’s a claim that discourages people from lynching him that he would know he could make without being countered - and he could judge reactions to try and guess at which town bloc was rolled - as there could potentially be upwards of four town players that knew this claim to be untrue.

You're hitting every point of why I thought he was scum D1. But Psychologist claim is just...soooo convenient. How would it be 4?

Sorry, technically 3 town aligned. In my head Lyncher Doctor is (was) basically a town PR with a self wincon that was slightly anti-town (there are plenty of worse third-party wincons).

[Swowl]

ok I am gonna leave yall to play with yourselves.

Mix - as you are tied for my primary push candidate, I would suggest you go re read some of my games.


Top picks for info IMO would be:

Skum - LOST Mafia
Town - Czech Mafia

[faust]

Okay, I made up my mind.

Vote: DatSwan

Further discussion only serves to out the real Psychologist. The people around who have already claimed should finish this off. So Galzria, can I ask you to hammer?