Okay, clarified most of those, thanks faust!
- You have Miller here but not Godfather. Intentional?
Actually yes! I want cops to be able to trust innocent results perfectly, I don't want things like Neapolitan to have that over them (also note that I don't have Vanilla cop, only Neapolitan, same logic basically.) But I like scum being able to fake claim Miller. That might be stupid and I should maybe just remove Miller...
I don't want to rule it out, but something that people could probably put together from things I've said in the past: I'm really unlikely to have an unlimited Cop anyway, 1 or 2-shot, Even-night, something like that at most really.
You may want to have a look at previous work by ashersky and me. This thread is also relevant. In particular I've noticed that you have kept the meaningless distinction between role and modifier from mafiascum. EDIT: I see that you have participated in the discussion way back when. I suppose you are already aware of this then.
I did look at both of those, I think in the past I even said something like "roles will be taken from faust's list or the mafiascum one" or something like that. Without looking back right now I seem to remember the idea of your lists being to list all (for some value of all) the common roles. I'm totally in favor of using Redirector or Bus Driver or some of the other ones in RMM or open normal games, but I'm trying to make a more limited list of the more predictable roles, and realized that what I see as the line between not-too-weird and what is most often used isn't really explicit and I wanted to reduce the outguessing-the-mod element to some extent.