Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[2.71828.....]

So frustrating.

I should have stuck to my conf!scum!UoS vote

[2.71828.....]

And yeah, game could have ended at the mislynch

[2.71828.....]

Like, just ugh.


But very good game. I really liked the double survivor that only wins with town thing. Well designed and I thought very balanced and good setup

[faust]

And yeah, game could have ended at the mislynch

joth had a window to redirect Awaclus's NK to UoS.

[2.71828.....]

And yeah, game could have ended at the mislynch

joth had a window to redirect Awaclus's NK to UoS.

Ah, interesting. Then yeah, had to go through the night.

I probably helped talking joth into believing we only had 1 scum left during twilight.

I should never have broken my unwritten rule of "never post anything in twilight as town or scum"

[2.71828.....]

Like, I really don't get why space did not feel comfortable claiming they were the other anaander after mail-mi died.

Mail-mi confirmed that the other anaander was town. Therefore when Awaclus claims other anaander they are confirmed town. Except they were lying scum. I feel like a full claim from space right there wins the game

[2.71828.....]

But I never should have lynched space.

Although it probably wouldn't have mattered since UoS could have lynched them for a likely win

[2.71828.....]

Unless joth or WCD decided to unvote.

[2.71828.....]

Also, I think Awaclus is MVP here. If I get a vote

[LaLight]

Also, I think Awaclus is MVP here. If I get a vote

[2.71828.....]

Also, people should sign up for deep space http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=19459.0

I need another game to be scummy town with overconfident reads that make no one believe me.

[Awaclus]

Thanks for the game, it was a fun one. The cultists were a pretty interesting mechanic, and I think the fact that there were two of them made the game pretty favored to scum. It could have been really bad for us if we had gotten copped by the Anaanders, but in this case it just helped us a little bit since xyrix got killed, and it could have helped a lot more if they had killed or recruited more town.

[LaLight]

another game where I continue telling myself to think about fakeclaim beforehand and then don't and then get screwed up over it

[Awaclus]

Also UoS did a lot of stuff in the scum QT, especially when he first joined the game, which made me all fired up to try a little harder myself so even though he wasn't super present in the main thread later on, his contributions shouldn't be undervalued.

[2.71828.....]

Thanks for the game, it was a fun one. The cultists were a pretty interesting mechanic, and I think the fact that there were two of them made the game pretty favored to scum. It could have been really bad for us if we had gotten copped by the Anaanders, but in this case it just helped us a little bit since xyrix got killed, and it could have helped a lot more if they had killed or recruited more town.

So, I agree slightly, but also the cultists could only win with town. So that *should* have made space an IC after mail-mi was lynched. Which would have helped a lot. Like, I would have never switched off UoS on D4 and they might have been lynched instead of ashersky.

Who knows.

I do think having only two scum would have been favored for town though

[2.71828.....]

Just read the speccy- nice call hypercube in /m11

[Awaclus]

FWIW on D2, my intention was not to save LaLight, it was to make myself look as towny as possible by doing the only thing I could think of that scum probably wouldn't do in the situation.

[Awaclus]

And yeah, game could have ended at the mislynch

joth had a window to redirect Awaclus's NK to UoS.

You mean the other way round? I wasn't an AI.

[faust]

And yeah, game could have ended at the mislynch

joth had a window to redirect Awaclus's NK to UoS.

You mean the other way round? I wasn't an AI.

Yes, sorry.

[SpaceAnemone]

Like, I really don't get why space did not feel comfortable claiming they were the other anaander after mail-mi died.

Mail-mi confirmed that the other anaander was town. Therefore when Awaclus claims other anaander they are confirmed town. Except they were lying scum. I feel like a full claim from space right there wins the game

I was really convinced that Joth was another Anaander, and I thought it was perfectly possible to have more than two, so it never seemed safe to claim.

[SpaceAnemone]

But I never should have lynched space.

Although it probably wouldn't have mattered since UoS could have lynched them for a likely win

You'd been super-suspicious of me for days, and I was townreading you until not long before your quicklynch show with Awaclus. If Awaclus hadn't RBd me N3 then you'd have had the full story in a recruiting QT.

[SpaceAnemone]

So, I agree slightly, but also the cultists could only win with town. So that *should* have made space an IC after mail-mi was lynched.

You keep saying that we could only win with town. That's not true: we could also win instead of town, by converting the last remaining townie before killing off the last red-flip player.

I even tried to make that clear in-thread sometime earlier in the game, because otherwise it would seem scummy if/when it did come out later that it was a possibility. I think Glooble agreed that it sounded possible but everyone else ignored it...

[SpaceAnemone]

Oh, hey. I just read the mod QT and discovered I was the intended N1 kill. That's unexpected even for me :-P

I'm looking forward to having time to read the scum QT later, but it looks too long to read from work..

faust, are you happy for players to post their own QTs now too?

[2.71828.....]

So, I agree slightly, but also the cultists could only win with town. So that *should* have made space an IC after mail-mi was lynched.

You keep saying that we could only win with town. That's not true: we could also win instead of town, by converting the last remaining townie before killing off the last red-flip player.

I even tried to make that clear in-thread sometime earlier in the game, because otherwise it would seem scummy if/when it did come out later that it was a possibility. I think Glooble agreed that it sounded possible but everyone else ignored it...

Ok, yeah. Better stated is that you couldn't win with scum.

I do wish that my recruitment had gone through

[faust]

Like, I really don't get why space did not feel comfortable claiming they were the other anaander after mail-mi died.

Mail-mi confirmed that the other anaander was town. Therefore when Awaclus claims other anaander they are confirmed town. Except they were lying scum. I feel like a full claim from space right there wins the game

I was really convinced that Joth was another Anaander, and I thought it was perfectly possible to have more than two, so it never seemed safe to claim.

I was quite hilarious that both Anaanders were hard-tunneling different players to be the other Anaander, neither of which really was the other Anaander. You were betting on joth, mail-mi was sure it was e.