I'm caught up!
I didn't quote block anything, which is what I had planned on doing when I set out to re-read, but that's life.
SS is a bad lynch. I've been decent at correctly reading him in the last few games I've played with him, both when he's town and when he's scum. He's a very consistent player, and his tone as either alignment can read VERY similar - but I've found him to be just a bit more subtle in how he tries to control the flow of things as scum - and I'm simply not seeing that here.
Faust also reads town to me right now - not that he's getting lynched anyway. Yes, he's asking a massive number of questions, which he does often as town, and mirrors well as scum - but it's how he asks them that tends to differentiate his alignments. When he's scum, I've found that his questions read as if he already knows the answer. He's not trying to deduce anything, or build reads - he asks questions for the sake of asking them, or to lead others astray.
Mcmc definitely comes across as the scummiest player to me - his opening post and vote on Swan feel VERY much like he's jumping in by leaning into his "I always fight with Swan" meta (which is DEFINITELY a thing that happens between them). But it's just so bloody obvious that... I can't decide if I feel like Mcmc is faking it, or if he's actually scummy because of it. Because I honestly believe that town!Mcmc would fake it for his own personal reasons, I'm hesitant to consider a lynch here.
Speaking of mcmc, I've found Datswan to be rather scummy as well. He too played in to the "I always fight with Mcmc" meta - but in a way that does NOT read like he's faking it for potentially pro-town reasons. Rather, his play feels much more like he's trying to force a match with his town meta, whereas Mcmc feels like he's almost intentionally being scummy. I would support this lynch.
Robz... My problem here is that I always find Robz scummy. He's a player I honestly just seem to have no ability to read whatsoever. I very much dislike the play and reads between him and Mcmc - but I'm probably more critical than I should be. Partially, I guess, I just don't trust ANY two players strong town reading each other (especially D1)!... While I'm extremely doubtful that they would make this play if they were both scum, I wouldn't be surprised to see that one of them was, and is playing into this brotherly-read.
Joth started out reading a little scummy, but has definitely played townier since then. It's really hard to make any sort of meta read here as well since it's been so long, but gut definitely feels town.
Jimmmmm/Dylan - I'm more or less neutral on. I think I find Dylan to be the townier of the two, but I don't have anything strong to go on. Certainly no real meta arguments. Just gut.
LaLight/Ashersky - I'm even more neutral on than Jimmm/Dylan.
And my "So-far-under-the-radar-even-though-they've-been-posting" player is UoS, who like Jimmmmm/Dylan/LL/Ash I have no real meta read to make, has just gut read scum to me. Like, serious under the radar scum. Don't know why. Can't point to anything they've said or done. May not even be anything to point to. Just how I felt every time I read their posts.
For now, I think I'm going to join Dylan on vote: Datswan. I think that was, and is, the best wagon we've had today.