Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EFHW]

Fang has done a lot of agreeing with me. It's gratifying, but not great scum partner play. I was thinking of it more along the lines of either buddying or recognition of my fundamental good sense . I also appreciated a number of his interventions Day 1. He zeroed in on some important things. I asked if he had played mafia before because I thought it would take a large amount of skill to pull off this towny a game as scum. He says he hasn't. The things I alluded to a few posts ago but didn't specify were basically related to agreeableness. Stating a few times that it's great that people are different, and conceding points quickly when given explanations.

POE is the main reason I am still on the fence about him.

[EFHW]

It would be good scum strategy to ally with a town player. Then if you get caught, you can bring the other person down with you.

[pingpongsam]

Finished another reread and I was definitely overlooking swan and Dylan. Swan seems to get exonerated on wagon analysis. Dylan is potentially a scumbag, though.

So, would lynch is fang, EFHW, Dylan, in that order.

[pingpongsam]

Does scum!EFHW stay on the scum!fang bus even as the connections are being made between them? I mean, do you throw the Hail Mary when there’s nothing but a field full of interceptors?

[EFHW]

Went through looking for hypercube references to fang.

At 276 he townreads me, pps and fang.

At 554 he says this:

I'll have to reread fang, some of the things he's said do seem scummy but that's what I thought in NM13 too and he turned out to be town there.

At 577 he says this:

I reread fang, he seems pretty similar to the town!fang I remember from NM13. He is unafraid to state his opinion on everything and his thought processes seem to come from a town perspective. I thought his proposed plan to lynch faust D1 was pro-town, it got some useful discussion going.

So I think I'll go back to vote: EFHW.

683 Says he wouldn't lynch fang.

[2.71828.....]

I will do a vote: fang

better than lynching EFHW. 

Sorry, I have have just not been useful today.

Priority to lynch: Datswan, Fang
Would lynch: WCD, Joseph
Not lynching today: EFHW, mcmc, Awaclus, Dylan
Not lynching: PPS, e

[EFHW]

Forgot to post this: I reread Days 1 and 2 focusing on me, fang and chairs/hypercube. Hyper goes after me pretty consistently, including accusing DatSwan of defending me, so don't agree there. I do see a fang/chairs partner thing just a bit. He asks for a prod on chairs, makes more than one comment about chairs' absence.

I also noticed I've been kind of cranky. Sorry.

[EFHW]

Time for sleeping. I'll be on before deadline, but not up to the exact time. I'll wait for a vote count to place a vote, but at this point I'm thinking fang.

[WestCoastDidds]

I think that was L-1...

Vote count 3.Didds

EFHW (3): mcmcsalot, Joseph2302, datswan
pingpongsam (1): pingpongsam
infangthief (4): Awaclus, WCD, Dylan, 2.718
Awaclus (1): infangthief
Not voting (1): EFHW

With 10 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day 3 ends Tuesday, 20th of November, at 11am.

[infangthief]

Dylan's vote for me seemed at least partly based on the idea of me being an informative flip.

But of course he won't get that information immediately, not till after tomorrow's lynch, so it made me do some thinking about how far through the game we are.

From this point, we can afford two mislynches and then we're at MYLO. Obviously better not to mislynch, but in worst case scenario, whoever we lynch today will definitely flip in time to inform our decisions at mylo. The same does not hold for tomorrow's lynch (we may get to know that flip before mylo, but only if we lynch scum today or tomorrow).

So if you think my flip will provide useful info, then yes, today is the day to do it. And probably the same goes for EFHW, I think there were comments that her lynch would be informative. In general, it makes sense for our lynch today to be guided a bit by how much info we'll get from the flip.

For me, my scum pool is {Awaclus, DatSwan, Dylan, Mcmc}. And I don't think we get so much info from any of those flips. I mean, maybe avoiding being a high-information flip is part of the strategy of being scum? But anyway, for a start, unvote: Awaclus - not the place to find information.

I'm sad that I've wasted today figuring out my position on EFHW. Well, I don't know, if I'd concluded she was scum that would have been useful I guess. But anyway, somehow I've ended up with a scum pool that I don't have strong feelings about. I think DatSwan's flip would be the most informative, so vote: DatSwan.

But yes, I guess for most of you it is EFHW or me, depending which one you think is scummier and which would be the more informative flip.

[pingpongsam]

Vote: fang

[infangthief]

Thanks guys.

[WestCoastDidds]

Good morning...any Tuesday I don’t have to go into work is sure to be a great day.

So that puts Fang on the guillotine? Sorry, dude, I know it feels crummy to be lynched. that is the only part of this game that I don’t think is fun. (And I know I’m one of the people doing it, but the cognitive dissonance is real!)

So, why are you voting for DatSwan? Is his role in the hyper lynch not persuasive to you?

[Joseph2302]

Been rereading quickly, was away all weekend
Fang is on the guillotine now but unfortunately we don't know alignment.
Interesting that EFHW wagon fell down during the day - not sure if that's a good or bad thing

[pingpongsam]

Half the reason to lynch fang today is because scum!EFHW would have far too much influence on guillotine. The other half being the likelihood of hitting scum, of course.

[mcmcsalot]

Between robz being ic a pps shooting hyper I actually forgot we were not going to get a flip. Tommorow is going tobe interesting with really no new information. Everyone should try to do some rereads and make notes in their qt’s so we come into the day with something to talk about.

[LaLight]

Thread locked. I am home in Moscow and I will be here from now on. Thousand times sorry for not being present, that is going to change.

[LaLight]

Vote count 3.3

EFHW (3): mcmcsalot, Joseph2302,, DatSwan
infangthief (5): Awaclus, WestCoastDidds, Dylan32, 2.71828....., pingpongsam
DatSwan (1): infangthief
Not voting (1): EFHW

With 10 alive, it took 5 to lynch.

infangthief is on the guillotine. Night 3 starts now and ends November 22 at 9:20 am.

[LaLight]

Flavor later

2.71828..... was killed. They was Mafia Goon, a Vanilla Townie


Day 4 starts now!

Vote count 4.0

Not voting (9): pingpongsam, Dylan32, DatSwan, Joseph2302, infangthief, Awaclus, WestCoastDidds, EFHW, mcmcsalot

infangthief is on the guillotine.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day 4 ends Thursday, 29th of November, at 12pm

Thread unlocked!

[WestCoastDidds]

Happy thanksgiving, friends who are being thankful and lazy today!

E, huh? That's interesting. He was the semi-confirmed town, but more dangerous to keep around than confirmed!town PPS? So, what was he saying that got him axed???

[WestCoastDidds]

Flavor later

2.71828..... was killed. They was Mafia Goon, a Vanilla Townie


Day 4 starts now!

Vote count 4.0

Not voting (10): pingpongsam, Dylan32, DatSwan, Joseph2302, infangthief, Awaclus, WestCoastDidds, EFHW, mcmcsalot, hypercube

infangthief is on the guillotine.
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day 4 ends Thursday, 29th of November, at 12pm

Thread unlocked!

LaLight, is that right? Is Hypercube back in the game?

[Joseph2302]

Happy thanksgiving, friends who are being thankful and lazy today!

E, huh? That's interesting. He was the semi-confirmed town, but more dangerous to keep around than confirmed!town PPS? So, what was he saying that got him axed???

I agree, e and not pps is damn crazy.
My only thought is it could be some elaborate stupid attempt at a double bluff.
Don't kill PPS and then people might think they're not actually the PR.
Either way, seems odd....

[infangthief]

LaLight, is that right? Is Hypercube back in the game?

Well spotted. Seems unlikely.
I think I'm still in the game though. Unlynchable too, which is nice in a way.

[infangthief]

Also, don't worry about lynching me; it means my alignment will get confirmed before Mylo at least, which I hope will be helpful.
Not quite lynched while at the dentist like you were. Lynched 24 hours before the dentist.

Happy Thanksgiving all.

[infangthief]

Happy thanksgiving, friends who are being thankful and lazy today!

E, huh? That's interesting. He was the semi-confirmed town, but more dangerous to keep around than confirmed!town PPS? So, what was he saying that got him axed???

I agree, e and not pps is damn crazy.
My only thought is it could be some elaborate stupid attempt at a double bluff.
Don't kill PPS and then people might think they're not actually the PR.
Either way, seems odd....

Yeh, e is a strange choice. I think e was actually a long way short of IC.
PPS has to have been the vig.