Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Basically this is a question on when-gain resolution.

When I gain a Crumbling Castle, two effects take place. Aqueduct gains me the VP on it, and I gain a Silver. I should be able to choose the Silver gain first, right? This would mean that I gain Crumbling Castle - first gain Silver - and then immediately take the VP from the Silver gain from Aqueduct. That is how I understand things, but it is not implemented that way in the online client. Am I misinterpreting the rules or is it a bug?

[fisherman]

That sounds like the right interpretation, so this would be a bug online. It's funny because with Harem I think the client still asks whether you want first to move the (non-existent) tokens from Harem to Aqueduct or to gain the Aqueduct points.

[Jeebus]

It's funny because with Harem I think the client still asks whether you want first to move the (non-existent) tokens from Harem to Aqueduct or to gain the Aqueduct points.

It even does this when you gain a Humble Castle.

[markus]

It indeed works for Humble Castle but not for Crumbling Castle. Probably because Humble Castle has both types, whereas for Crumbling Castle the client forgets that you're still gaining a victory card by the time you gain the Silver.